document.md

Download raw Markdown
Sections in document.md

USD SOFR OIS Discount Curve — Methodology Document

Document version: demo-v1
Document date: 2026-10-12
As-of date: 2026-09-18; spot date: 2026-09-22
Status: for documentation readiness assessment
Fictional inventory: HER-QM-017 (simulated)
Source revision: 01ae3bdac6f61ecbabcd72e0116ebb2860e93157

This methodology demonstration combines real historical public data, derived numerical evidence and an explicitly fictional institution dossier. It is not a live pricing service, an approved production model or a complete regulatory submission. All institutional roles, policies, records and controls are simulated; actual institutional evidence and authorization remain outside this demonstration.

The model converts a historical SOFR fixing and estimated swap rates into the present value of future USD payments and the compounded SOFR rates consistent with those values. The developer chooses method B, monotone-convex forward interpolation, principally because its projected forwards are continuous and show smaller observed changes than method A, log-linear discount factors. The tradeoff is wider sensitivity spillover and substantial long-end uncertainty: the largest observed disagreement is about USD 227,458 for one USD 100 million payment on 2050-04-18, not a portfolio gain or loss. [BRIEF, Model and choice 1; RESULTS, df_difference_A_minus_B_monthly_grid, forward_smoothness, locality_bump_5Y_plus_1bp.]

The curve is a single-currency, single-curve analytical construction calibrated to two deposits and twenty overnight-indexed swaps (OIS). Inputs are a published historical fixing and derived close-adjusted medians of reported executions; they are not a licensed closing curve. Harbor Example Research is fictional and proposes only sandbox explanation, historical comparison and illustrative sensitivity work. Read Section 5 for the interpolation decision, Section 7 for its measured support, and Sections 8–10 for reliance limits, assumptions and unresolved authorization. [BRIEF, Model; QUOTES, tenor table; INST, Inventory and intended use.]

1. Purpose and scope

Discounting translates a promised payment at a future date into a present value. A discount factor of 0.80 means that one dollar paid on that date has a model value of eighty cents at the curve's as-of date. Projection uses the same curve to infer the compounded overnight SOFR accrual between two dates; it is a rate implied by this construction rather than a forecast that future published fixings will equal it. The Secured Overnight Financing Rate (SOFR) is the underlying overnight reference rate identified in the retained New York Fed fixing. This document concerns the curve's implementation, its historical evidence and the fictional research scenario, rather than a transaction recommendation. [BRIEF, Model and Par relation; FIXING, last_known_fixing_date, sofr_percent; HW-CODE, Ois, ois_par_rate.]

The reader's decision is whether the developer's choice is understandable and sufficiently documented for a separate assessment. Both methods are intended to fit the same instruments; exact calibration alone therefore cannot choose between them. The relevant distinction is how each fills the spaces between quoted maturities and how that choice changes projected forwards and sensitivities. B is the developer's preferred interpolation for projection. A provides a transparent comparison and a more local risk pattern on the retained tests. No model validity certification follows from either statement. [BRIEF, choice 1 and smaller choice “Method A as the comparison method”; RESULTS, comparison metrics.]

The fictional commission records an explanation of historical inputs as of 2026-09-18. The proposed sandbox would support hypothetical SOFR-discounted USD cash flows and single-curve compounded-SOFR OIS; the dossier authorizes no production use or trading. There is no real portfolio, actual customer exposure or live downstream integration. The USD 100 million notional used in numerical examples is a unit exposure, not a position inventory. The numerical run occurred historically in October; its receipts are evidence about that calculation, not a record of current deployment. [INST, Inventory and intended use; ENV, stage timestamps.]

The method supplies dated discount factors through the last 30Y instrument and an explicit extrapolation beyond it. Prices can be evaluated at intermediate dates, but the information supplied by the market remains concentrated at eligible OIS tenors. A visually smooth interpolated curve does not add observations between those tenors. This is especially consequential between 20Y and 30Y, where the retained 20Y quote has six prints and only USD 0.04 billion reported notional after rounding. [QUOTES, 20Y row; RESULTS, forward comparison; BRIEF, choice 1.]

2. Product and portfolio coverage

The covered analytical products are USD cash flows assumed to be discounted at SOFR and OIS whose floating leg compounds SOFR daily in arrears. A single curve both discounts and projects that rate. This is an explicit modeling scope: other collateral rates or currencies would require different discounting, and other projected rates cannot be inferred merely by relabeling the SOFR curve. [BRIEF, Model, Scope and exclusions.]

Excluded uses include a separate projection/discount multi-curve framework, tenor basis, cross-currency basis, collateral-choice or credit support annex (CSA) specific discounting, term SOFR, SOFR futures and their convexity adjustment, and explicit central-bank-meeting or year-end jumps. The implementation does not model option volatility, dynamic scenarios or transaction costs. The first seven exclusions are supplied developer scope; the latter absence follows from the static cash-flow equations and retained input set, rather than evidence that such risks are immaterial. [BRIEF, Scope and exclusions, choices 5–6; BOOT, ql_helpers; HW-CODE, ois_par_rate.]

Calibration swaps run from 1M to 30Y after spot, with missing 9M and 25Y tenors. The overnight and tom-next deposits bridge the as-of date to spot. The monthly comparison grid runs from 2026-09-18 to 2056-09-18, whereas the final instrument payment node is 2056-09-26. These are different horizons. Beyond that node the curve is extrapolated; the 40Y illustration is not calibrated to a 40Y quote. [GRID, first/last rows; NODES, O/N, T/N and 30Y rows; RESULTS, extrapolation.]

[INSTITUTIONAL GAP: Actual usage and exposure inventory, customer positions and deployed downstream consumers are unavailable.]

[INSTITUTIONAL GAP: The actual production instrument set, collateral terms and approved convention set are unavailable.]

3. Model description and theory

3.1 Cash-flow relations and conventions

Let (Z(t)) be the dimensionless present value at 2026-09-18 of USD 1 paid on date (t), with (Z(0)=1). Curve time (T(t)) is Actual/365 Fixed from that date. The continuously compounded zero rate and instantaneous forward are

\[
r(t)=-\frac{\log Z(t)}{T(t)},\qquad
Z(t)=\exp\left[-\int_0^{T(t)} f(u)\,du\right].
\]

Zero rates at time zero are undefined in the monthly CSV, which records nan; this is not a missing nonzero-date discount factor. Percentage zero rates multiply the rate by 100. One basis point (bp) is 0.0001 in rate units. Changing the descriptive time basis changes quoted zero rates, not the discount factors being described. [BOOT, T, CurveSet.zero, monthly-grid writer; HW-CODE, integral, discount; BRIEF, smaller construction choices.]

A simple Act/360 deposit of rate (q), start (s), end (e), and accrual fraction (\alpha) imposes (Z(e)=Z(s)/(1+q\alpha)). Both retained deposits use 3.85%: O/N from 2026-09-18 to 2026-09-21 and T/N from 2026-09-21 to 2026-09-22. These dates span four calendar days and two SOFR business days. The input is the fixing effective 2026-09-17, published 2026-09-18, so the later fixing bearing the as-of date is not used with hindsight. [BRIEF, Instruments and conventions, choice 4; FIXING; HW-CODE, bootstrap deposit construction.]

For OIS period (k), let (s_k,e_k,p_k) denote accrual start, accrual end and payment date, and let (\alpha_k) be its Act/360 accrual fraction. The fixed rate equates discounted fixed and floating payments:

\[
R=\frac{\sum_k \left[Z(s_k)/Z(e_k)-1\right]Z(p_k)}
{\sum_k \alpha_k Z(p_k)}.
\]

The projected daily factors telescope to (Z(s_k)/Z(e_k)) under this single-curve construction. Payment discounting uses (p_k), not (e_k). Thus the floating leg does not generally reduce to a single difference of discount factors when there is a payment lag. For one accrual period the common pay-date factor cancels from the par ratio, which helps explain why a quote may not pin the very last payment-date discount factor directly. This relation is implemented in ois_par_rate; the brief describes it as a generalization of HW2006 equation (1), an attribution to the developer rather than a newly verified reading of the paper. [HW-CODE, Ois, ois_par_rate; BRIEF, Par relation.]

Spot is two business days after trade date. Fixed and floating legs use annual schedules, with one payment for maturities up to one year, Act/360 accrual, and payment two business days after accrual end using Following. The brief identifies backward accrual-date generation in twelve-month steps with Modified Following. Both methods obtain dates from QuantLib's SOFR calendar and the same helper objects. Payment dates are the nodes: the 2Y accrual maturity is 2028-09-22 but the node is 2028-09-26. The gap between accrual end and payment is interpolated. Thus equal instrument repricing does not require equal node zero rates: at 1M, A is 3.9407% and B is 3.9477%. [BRIEF, Instruments and conventions; BOOT, ql_helpers, hw_instruments; NODES, 1M and 2Y rows.]

3.2 Interpolation and solution

Write (t_i=T(\text{node}i)), (h_i=t_i-t{i-1}), and (d_i=-\log[Z(t_i)/Z(t_{i-1})]/h_i). Method A linearly interpolates log discount factors: inside interval (i), (\log Z(t)=\log Z(t_{i-1})-d_i(t-t_{i-1})). Its instantaneous forward is constant on each interval. A's QuantLib implementation is PiecewiseLogLinearDiscount; the separately written LogLinearDiscount class represents the same construction. The rates can jump at a node because adjacent (d_i) need not coincide. [BOOT, CurveSet; HW-CODE, LogLinearDiscount.]

Method B constructs node forwards from adjacent discrete forwards. At an interior node,

\[
f_i=\frac{h_i d_{i+1}+h_{i+1}d_i}{h_i+h_{i+1}},\qquad
f_0=d_1-\tfrac12(f_1-d_1),\qquad
f_n=d_n-\tfrac12(f_{n-1}-d_n).
\]

The optional positivity collar clips the first and final forwards to the interval from zero to twice the adjacent discrete forward, and each interior forward to zero through (2\min(d_i,d_{i+1})). On each interval, (x=(t-t_{i-1})/h_i), (g_0=f_{i-1}-d_i), (g_1=f_i-d_i), and (f(t)=d_i+g(x)). Sector (i) uses

\[
g(x)=g_0(1-4x+3x^2)+g_1(-2x+3x^2).
\]

The other sectors replace inappropriate shapes with flat pieces joined to quadratics, or two quadratics meeting at an interior value. The _sector, _g and _G functions specify the complete branches and their analytic integrals. Integration gives (Z(t)=\exp[-\int_0^t f]) and preserves each interval's discrete forward; merely interpolating node forwards without that integral constraint would be a different method. The chosen implementation is the developer's unameliorated Hagan–West account, with equations identified in the code comments as HW2008 (22)–(34). No general theorem about every admissible input is established by the retained snapshot. [HW-CODE, MonotoneConvex, _sector, _g, _G; BRIEF, choice 1.]

Deposit intervals are fixed analytically. The remaining discrete forwards are solved simultaneously so all twenty OIS par residuals vanish. SciPy root(method="hybr") uses each swap rate as an initial forward guess, tolerance (10^{-14}), and a maximum 20,000 function evaluations; the code raises an error if the largest remaining par-rate residual exceeds (10^{-11}) in rate units. These are solver settings, distinct from the fictional house's 0.01 bp instrument criterion. Neighboring intervals influence B's interpolation, which explains the developer's simultaneous solve and its broader sensitivity. There is no general convergence proof in this evidence. [HW-CODE, bootstrap; HOUSE, Modeling choices and tests.]

Beyond the last node, each method holds its own final instantaneous forward constant. Thus (Z(t)=Z(t_n)\exp[-f(t_n)(t-t_n)]). A holds the last interval forward; B holds its end-rule value. This is an explicit continuation assumption, not information from a traded long-maturity instrument. [HW-CODE, both integral methods; BRIEF, choice 7.]

4. Inputs and data

4.1 Lineage, timing and transformations

Table 1. Input classes for the 2026-09-18 snapshot. Units and date roles distinguish source observations, transformations and scenario facts.

InputMeaning, timing and unitTransformation and quality limitSource
Retained NY Fed fixing3.85% effective 2026-09-17, published 2026-09-18; retained volume USD 2,992 billionAssumed constant to spot; subsequent 2026-09-18 and 2026-09-21 fixings are ex-post evidence onlyFIXING, named fields
DTCC cumulative rates reportReport date 2026-09-18; execution times converted to New YorkPublic trade prints, not executable offers or a closing fixing; raw archive omittedQUOTES, filter account; PROVENANCE
Close-adjusted OIS estimatesMedian rate (%) at hour 16 New York; IQR in bpOne common intraday path and tenor loading; statistical estimate from filtered executionsQUOTES, tenor/path/loading tables; DERIVE
Instrument datesSpot 2026-09-22; accrual/pay/node datesShared QuantLib SOFR calendar, Act/360 accrual and Act/365F curve time; independent calendar reconciliation absentBOOT, helpers/instruments; NODES
Fictional house and dossierHER-scenario-1, authored 2026-10-12Simulated roles, thresholds and records; no operating evidenceHOUSE; INST

Source: sofr_fixing.json, quotes.md, derive_quotes.py, bootstrap.py, institution.md. Values in this table are supplied, not new market observations.

The developer selects NEWT/TRAD USD SOFR OIS executions on the as-of New York date, effective at spot, without package flags or upfront payments, with an A004 fixed-leg code and annual or expiry-only schedules on both legs. Maturities within four calendar days of a standard tenor are matched. The report has 23,563 rows and 4,258 new USD SOFR OIS trades; 663 spot prints pass the filters, 529 match standard tenors, and the twenty eligible tenor sets supply 523 calibration-tenor prints. The six-print difference is the four 9M and two 25Y observations excluded by the count rule. A tenor requires at least five prints and adjusted IQR no greater than 2 bp; dispersion excludes none on this date. [QUOTES, filter paragraphs and tenor rows; DERIVE, MIN_TRADES, MAX_IQR_BP, tenor eligibility condition.]

Across all effective dates the filter account excludes 76 monthly-paying and 309 otherwise qualifying prints carrying another payment. In the separate population of 4,051 as-of executions including packages, 1,661 have another payment and 2,390 do not; 26% versus 3% have fixed rates on round 5 bp steps. This supports the developer's concern that standard coupons with upfronts need not be par rates. These denominators differ from 663 spot prints and should not be combined. Of 4,258 new trades, 4,211 use A004; 47 with other or blank codes are excluded rather than converted. The interpretation of A004 as Actual360 is the brief's account of the historical CFTC specification. [QUOTES, filter and code-count paragraphs; BRIEF, choice 3 and smaller selection choices.]

Twenty of the 529 matched prints remain more than 5 bp from their adjusted tenor medians, with deviations 5.7–154.3 bp. They are retained to avoid tuning an exclusion rule; the developer reports that removing them moves no used quote more than 0.124 bp. Median robustness does not prove every retained print is a valid par execution, particularly at a thin tenor. A count floor of ten would remove 1M, 2M, 18M, 8Y, 9Y, 12Y, 15Y and 20Y, illustrating the tradeoff between coverage and depth. [QUOTES, off-market paragraph; BRIEF, choice 3.]

4.2 Derived close and tenor evidence

For execution (j) at hour (h) and tenor (m), the estimate is (r_j^{close}=r_j-\lambda_m P_h), where (P_{16}=0). Median regression (QuantReg, quantile 0.5) fits a common path on tenors at least 2Y with loading one. The retained path is −6.8 bp at hour 00, −2.8 bp at hour 08 and zero at hour 16; its minimum displayed value is −8.2 bp at hour 02, so the movement is not a monotonic rise. The developer's “about 7 bp” describes the start-to-close level difference. The close is the last traded hour, 16:00–16:59, not an instantaneous published fixing. [DERIVE, path fit and close_adj; QUOTES, common intraday path.]

Short-tenor loadings require at least eight prints in five distinct hours; otherwise they are interpolated. Fitted loadings include 3M 0.08, 4M 0.15, 6M 0.14, 1Y 0.49 and 18M 0.86. The 1M fitted −0.04 is clipped to zero; 2M is interpolated at 0.04. All loadings are constrained to [0,1]; fitted long-tenor values range 0.97–1.08 but are used as one. Forward-starting trades take the loading of time from as-of to expiration, treating a one-year swap starting in one year like a two-year maturity for this adjustment. This rule avoids a forward-start model but ignores start/length differences. [QUOTES, loading table; DERIVE, loading_for; BRIEF, choice 2 and smaller close-adjustment choices.]

For maturities of at least 1Y, adjusted within-tenor IQRs are 0.1–0.8 bp versus 1.7–5.8 bp raw. The raw 4Y median is 5.9 bp below 3Y after rounding, a pattern the developer attributes to execution timing. Narrowing is partly in-sample because the path fits the same prints. Leave-one-tenor-out refits move a path tenor's quote by at most 0.165 bp; that tests own-tenor path influence, not short-tenor loading estimation or an independent closing level. Alternatives are unadjusted all-day medians, late-hours-only medians, least-squares fits, or a licensed closing curve; none supplies a demonstrated superior estimate here. [QUOTES, tenor and leave-one-out tables; BRIEF, choice 2.]

Table 2. Derived OIS quote evidence, as-of 2026-09-18, spot 2026-09-22. Trades and within-1-bp values are counts; rates are percent, dispersion is bp, notional is USD billion. These are historical estimates.

TenorTradesQuote: close-adjusted median (%)IQR adjusted (bp)Within 1 bp of quoteRaw median (%)IQR raw (bp)Notional (USD bn)Used
1M83.89740.183.89740.19.67yes
2M53.96830.153.96780.13.39yes
3M174.03190.3174.02950.38.81yes
4M104.10310.2104.09910.44.32yes
6M104.20570.3104.20070.70.92yes
9M44.36990.544.34921.10.18no
1Y414.49870.7354.47783.35.31yes
18M94.58680.384.56914.50.23yes
2Y514.63580.3444.60605.64.00yes
3Y254.63420.5244.62064.51.43yes
4Y334.61070.6314.56125.20.62yes
5Y764.59680.6694.58034.24.63yes
6Y124.59170.5124.57784.30.39yes
7Y424.59230.7384.57325.11.90yes
8Y84.59640.584.54115.80.11yes
9Y84.61070.384.58972.40.13yes
10Y994.62080.8884.60672.22.76yes
12Y54.65820.244.64551.70.09yes
15Y74.70850.564.69822.10.08yes
20Y64.74770.144.72783.70.04yes
25Y24.71890.024.71460.20.01no
30Y514.66370.8474.64952.20.60yes

Source: QUOTES, quotes.md tenor table and quotes.csv, originally calculated by derive_quotes.py. Retained displayed precision is preserved; “Used” applies to the bootstrap eligibility rule.

5. Method choices and rationale

5.1 Principal choice: measured disagreement and tradeoff

Define the largest observed present-value disagreement as

\[
\max_{t\in G} 100{,}000{,}000\,|Z_A(t)-Z_B(t)|,
\]

where (G) is the 361-date SOFR-calendar-adjusted monthly grid from 2026-09-18 through 2056-09-18 inclusive. The retained maximum is USD 227,458.20 on 2050-04-18, from a dimensionless difference 0.0022745819731463945. Displayed discount factors are 0.33209463 for A and 0.32982005 for B; A minus B is positive at that date. This is the disagreement for one specified USD 100 million cash flow, not profit, an observed loss, portfolio risk, or proof that either curve is correct. The exact currency conversion uses retained JSON precision; the rounded CSV values alone should not support cents. [RESULTS, df_difference_A_minus_B_monthly_grid; GRID, 2050-04-18 row; BOOT, monthly grid and NOTIONAL.]

Table 3. A/B method comparison, as-of 2026-09-18. Historical measures use shared quotes, fixing, instrument dates and conventions; no general superiority threshold is supplied for shape or locality.

Criterion and populationA: log-linear DFB: monotone convexMeasure and locator
Largest instrument repricing error (bp), all 22 inputs3.8601e-92.7554e-10Absolute model-minus-input rate; RESULTS repricing_max_abs_error_bp; criterion ≤0.01 bp each
Largest successive-business-day forward move (bp), as-of through last node59.711.68Maximum absolute change of Act/360 overnight forward; forward_smoothness
Moves above 2 bp (count), same grid180Diagnostic threshold, not acceptance rule; same fields
Largest five-business-day forward change (bp), same grid59.735.34Absolute endpoint difference, not cumulative variation; same fields
Total forward variation (bp), same grid421.3365.0Sum of absolute successive changes; forward_total_variation_bp
5Y +1 bp: largest absolute forward change outside [4Y,6Y] (bp)0.03054.1475Dates strictly outside 2030-09-25 through 2032-09-24; locality_bump_5Y_plus_1bp
4.5Y payment: share of absolute PV sensitivity outside 4Y/5Y (%)5.8611.94Sum of absolute individual quote-bump PV changes outside / sum across twenty OIS inputs; pv_ladder_4p5y
Zero rate on maximum-disagreement date (%)4.67154.7006Continuous Act/365F; GRID 2050-04-18
Extrapolated discount factor at 40Y (dimensionless)0.164260430.16853911No 40Y quote; extrapolation

Source: results.json, df_grid_monthly.csv, calculated historically by bootstrap.py and hagan_west.py. Rounded displays retain their source precision; thresholds are from HOUSE where stated.

The developer's reason for B is its projection shape, with a smaller benefit for some short broken dates. B's continuity does not imply uniform smoothness: sectors (ii) and (iii) insert flat stretches, and after the 3Y node its overnight forward falls from 4.4705% to 4.4317% in three business days. The no-jumps-above-2-bp statistic alone would miss that short ramp. B uses sectors i/ii/iii/iv on 10/4/3/5 intervals and the positivity collar binds at zero nodes on this date. [BRIEF, choice 1; RESULTS, forward_after_3Y_node, hagan_west_sectors, hagan_west_collar_binding_nodes.]

A's cleaner local risk can matter for instrument-by-instrument hedging. B's 5Y bump modifies the 4Y–5Y discrete forward, which changes the node forward at 4Y and bends the preceding 3Y–4Y interval; the largest response outside the chosen window is just after the 3Y node. This causal explanation follows the neighboring-forward formula, not an inference that the 3Y input changed. The test uses a mid-curve 5Y tenor with 76 prints; 10Y, with 99, is the most-traded path tenor. It is one quote bump and one cash-flow ladder, not a stability norm over every cash flow and input. [BRIEF, smaller test choices; QUOTES, 5Y/10Y rows; HW-CODE, node formula; BUMP, rows near 2029-09-26.]

The long end exposes the interpolation assumption most strongly. The low 20Y–30Y discrete forward lowers B's 20Y node forward and influences the previous interval from about 18Y; the end condition then places the final forward below the interval's average. B's Act/360 overnight forward moves from 4.6127% at 20Y to 3.9957% at 30Y; its business-day average over the interval is 4.2013%. The end is about 20.6 bp below that average and about 67 bp below the 30Y par rate, 4.6637%. A holds approximately 4.2248%. The average refers to starts on business days from 2046-09-26 to the day before 2056-09-26; it is not the Act/365F discrete forward or a par rate. The developer describes the final-node condition as imposing zero instantaneous-forward slope at 30Y, extending the preceding curve shape. Sparse inputs and that end rule determine this shape; price evidence does not identify it uniquely. [RESULTS, comparison table; QUOTES, 30Y; BRIEF, choice 1; BOOT, long-end average calculation.]

Historical discount-factor comparison

Figure 1. As-of 2026-09-18 discount factors (dimensionless) against years from as-of (Act/365F), comparing A and B on the historical monthly grid, with the time-zero point omitted by the plotting code. Frozen figure fig_discount_factors.png, from bootstrap.py using df_grid_monthly.csv, quotes.csv and sofr_fixing.json. The curves overlap visually over much of the domain; this scale does not establish numerical equality or eliminate the single-payment disagreement above.

Historical overnight-forward comparison

Figure 2. As-of 2026-09-18 Act/360 simple overnight forwards (%) against years from as-of (Act/365F), on SOFR business-day starts through one year beyond the last node. Frozen fig_forwards.png, bootstrap.py, forward_daily.csv. “Overnight” accrues to the next business day and can span a weekend. The plot displays A's staircase and B's continuous construction and flat extrapolation; it does not show realized future rates or establish a preferred shape in an untested regime.

5.2 Alternatives and remaining construction choices

QuantLib's convex-monotone default blend, quadraticity 0.3 and monotonicity 0.7, converges but is not the selected paper setting. Its maximum monthly-grid absolute DF difference from B is 8.01175e-5 and largest daily forward move 20.56 bp. The paper-setting variant (0,1) fails in QuantLib's iterative bootstrap at the 3M instrument, with “root not bracketed”; that failed solver attempt is not a successful alternative curve and does not establish that B's simultaneous system is impossible. The uncollared B variant converges and is identical in the retained result because the collar does not bind. These variants have only the reported subset of tests; cubic splines were rejected by the developer for positivity/locality concerns attributed to HW2008 Table 1 and were not built. [RESULTS, interpolation_variants; BRIEF, choice 1.]

The developer keeps A as a transparent mistake-finding reference, attributing that practice to HW2008; A is not demonstrated to be the best competitor. Using shared dates isolates interpolation comparisons conditional on those dates, at the cost of shared schedule defects. Placing nodes at payment dates follows the selected helper pillars; using final accrual ends instead was considered, but changes the few interpolated days beyond each instrument's accrual. Act/365F time and continuous compounding are descriptive choices; Act/360 time was an alternative. The positivity collar is intended to preserve positive forwards with positive discrete inputs, while flattening can occur where it binds; a no-collar alternative was actually measured. Simultaneous solving replaces possible node-by-node fixed-point iteration because of neighboring-interval dependence, without a general convergence guarantee. [BRIEF, Smaller choices—Construction; HW-CODE, collar, solution and interpolation functions.]

The other principal choices are deliberately narrow. OIS-only calibration avoids absent futures settlement data and the developer's cited need for a convexity adjustment, at the cost of front-end detail. Single-curve construction avoids a broader multi-curve framework and projects only SOFR. The last known fixing bridges to spot without pre-swap interpolation; starting at spot or using a later published fixing were alternatives, but the latter would introduce unavailable-at-close information. Flat final-forward extrapolation follows the developer's attribution to HW2006 p.109; a long-rate assumption or institution-specific policy would be different alternatives and is not supplied. [BRIEF, choices 4–7.]

Selection choices also affect the curve: a four-calendar-day maturity allowance absorbs weekends/holidays but may admit an unusual stub; exact-date matching or recomputed business-adjusted dates would be alternatives. New York dating aligns executions with the chosen close instead of the report's UTC day, but can include evening executions. Keeping packages, converting other schedules, converting non-A004 day counts, raising the print count floor, removing off-market prints or dropping the dispersion test are alternative designs, not results of this model. Each has a supplied reason for rejection or deferral; none is silently assumed to have been tested. [BRIEF, choice 3 and Smaller choices—Print selection.]

5.3 Estimation and test-design decisions

The developer describes public dissemination as the available free, date-specific citable source for this example; the stronger claim that it is the only such source is the developer's rationale, not an independently established market-data survey. Packages are excluded because a leg's rate can reflect a package-wide bargain. Five sufficiently tight prints are considered by the developer enough to locate a median within 1 bp; this is a judgment rather than an established sampling-error guarantee. Replacing the derived inputs with the institution's own reconciled market data is proposed for any deployment. [BRIEF, choices 2–3; INST, Data lineage.]

Table 3a. Additional estimator decisions for the 2026-09-18 snapshot. Reasons are developer statements, with alternatives and limits preserved.

DecisionDeveloper's reasonAlternativeLimitation
Median regressionAlign robust path fitting with median quotesLeast squares, possibly after trimmingNo least-squares comparison is supplied
Common path fitted at 2Y and longer with loading oneSeparate fitted loadings are near one; shorter tenors move lessFit each tenor's loadingSmall long-tenor movement differences are ignored
At least eight prints across five hours to fit a loadingSparse time coverage cannot separate a level from movementFit every tenorInterpolated 2M loading is an assumption
Clip loadings to zero through oneNegative or above-long-tenor movement has no economic reading for this day in the developer's viewUnconstrained fit1M's −0.04 estimate becomes zero
Last traded hour defines closeLatest observed hour among path tenorsA fixed clock time such as 15:00Hour average/median reference is not a published closing fixing
Forward-start loading follows expiration distanceSimple rule without a forward-start modelDepend on both start and swap lengthOne-year-forward one-year swap receives a two-year-maturity loading

Source: BRIEF, Smaller choices—Close adjustment; QUOTES, path/loading tables; DERIVE, regression and loading_for code. Print counts are counts, hours are distinct New York clock hours, loadings are dimensionless.

The selected 5Y +1 bp perturbation is motivated by a liquid mid-curve quote; the developer attributes the 1 bp convention to HW2008 p.78 and the 4.5Y cash flow to HW2006 p.126. Bumping every input and reporting a stability norm would answer a broader question. The maximum single-cash-flow money measure expresses an interpolation choice in desk currency units, while a diversified portfolio comparison would require an actual portfolio and could offset differences. Leave-one-tenor-out tests whether a tenor drives its own path adjustment; cross-validation over hours is an alternative, and fitted short-tenor loadings remain outside that check. [BRIEF, Smaller choices—Tests.]

The 1 bp outside-input tolerance is a developer judgment relative to observed quote dispersion; a tolerance by maturity bucket was an alternative. The paired sign test avoids a residual-size model and counts the closer curve; t-tests and Wilcoxon tests were alternatives. Agreement tolerances at rounding scale, half printed paper precision, numerical quadrature scale and daily-grid approximation scale address different numerical questions; tightening or loosening them would require a stated reason. None becomes a production acceptance policy merely by being used in the historical tests. [BRIEF, Check tolerances and other test choices; CHECKS, named checks.]

6. Implementation notes

The original source revision identifies all copied calculation code. derive_quotes.py reads the raw report and historical rate snapshots, filters and adjusts prints, and writes quote/fixing summaries. bootstrap.py supplies the common QuantLib instrument construction, builds A and B, evaluates grids, bumps and convention variants, and writes figures. hagan_west.py supplies B's interpolation, analytic integral, simple deposit/OIS representations, simultaneous calibration and the separately written log-linear class. verify.py supplies developmental checks and pricing outside the input set. summarize_implementations.py and summarize_residuals.py provide the retained supplements. run_recorded.py records stage execution and package checks. [WE, Calculation source; corresponding public script functions; ENV.]

Table 4. Historical calculation receipts for the 2026-09-18 inputs. Times are UTC on 2026-10-02 and are supplied receipt values.

StageStart (UTC)Finish (UTC)Retained state / exit code (integer)
Quote derivation04:15:17.70129304:15:18.632378completed / 0
Bootstrap04:15:18.73717204:15:20.209686completed / 0
Verification04:15:20.29961804:15:21.088870completed / 0
Residual supplement04:15:21.16586904:15:21.171377completed / 0
Implementation supplement05:00:42.42289705:00:49.979153completed / 0

Source: ENV, evidence/environment/{derive-quotes,bootstrap,verify,residual-summary,implementation-summary}.json, started_utc, finished_utc, state, exit_code. These identify historical executions only.

Historical Python is 3.12.14, QuantLib 1.43 and SciPy 1.18.1; stage receipts also identify NumPy 2.5.3, pandas 3.0.6, statsmodels 0.15.0 and matplotlib 3.11.2 where used. The residual summary uses Python's standard library. These are reported historical package identities, not a declaration that the same environment runs in an actual institution. Original script and input hashes are retained in the provenance manifest and receipt JSON. [ENV, run_info.json, required_packages, installed_packages; DISTANCE, metadata.]

Reproducibility has two levels. The selective public bundle allows inspection of instrument-level residuals, monthly DF differences, the 7,482-date implementation series, distance-bin arithmetic, and the code's conventions without executing a model. It cannot support a complete offline raw-data rerun: the original DTCC ZIP, raw extracted trade tables, original NY Fed snapshots and third-party PDFs are omitted. The original DTCC SHA-256 is 03a09a0ec9c5c5d1e233c2b663cb21d7c36b64573ef9ad5d587a874c5a7ba036; original rate-snapshot hashes are listed in original-raw-input-hashes.txt. Reacquiring raw inputs, checking their identities and preparing the numerical environment would be separate work. A matching output hash confirms bytes, not the truth of every claim or independent model validation. [WE, Evidence scope and exclusions; PROVENANCE; RAW-HASHES.]

7. Testing and benchmarking

7.1 Calibration and developmental checks

Table 5. All 22 calibration instruments, as-of 2026-09-18. Errors are implied minus input par rate (bp); the selected house criterion is absolute error ≤0.01 bp for every row in each method.

InstrumentInput rate (%)A error (bp)B error (bp)Within criterion, A/B
O/N3.850000-9.090e-12-9.090e-12yes / yes
T/N3.8500005.238e-10-2.755e-10yes / yes
1M3.8974001.395e-11-1.263e-11yes / yes
2M3.968300-4.191e-11-3.261e-12yes / yes
3M4.031900-4.642e-11-2.498e-12yes / yes
4M4.103100-1.467e-10-2.567e-12yes / yes
6M4.205700-3.860e-09-2.082e-13yes / yes
1Y4.498700-9.506e-121.388e-12yes / yes
18M4.586800-6.245e-13-2.082e-13yes / yes
2Y4.6358009.190e-109.714e-13yes / yes
3Y4.6342006.939e-144.163e-13yes / yes
4Y4.6107004.372e-126.939e-14yes / yes
5Y4.5968004.857e-132.776e-13yes / yes
6Y4.591700-2.776e-134.857e-13yes / yes
7Y4.592300-2.082e-13-6.939e-14yes / yes
8Y4.596400-5.551e-133.469e-13yes / yes
9Y4.610700-5.412e-122.776e-13yes / yes
10Y4.620800-1.527e-124.163e-13yes / yes
12Y4.658200-3.483e-113.469e-13yes / yes
15Y4.708500-1.388e-132.082e-13yes / yes
20Y4.7477000.000e+001.388e-13yes / yes
30Y4.6637003.518e-112.082e-13yes / yes

Source: REPRICE, repricing.csv, all instrument rows; historical bootstrap.py. The criterion comparison is a current arithmetic check of frozen error columns, not a new calibration run.

Both methods satisfy the fictional criterion on every retained calibration instrument. The tiny nonzero errors measure numerical solver tolerance, not market error. Identical rounded implied/market percentages alone would not establish this result; the error columns preserve finer information. [REPRICE, all rows; RESULTS, repricing_max_abs_error_bp; HOUSE, Modeling choices and tests.]

Table 6. Retained developmental checks, as-of 2026-09-18 unless a paper example or flat synthetic curve is specified. All “pass” results below are historical verify.py records, not tests performed anew.

Check and exact scopeHistorical measured result (unit)Supplied tolerance / interpretation
Paper example attributed to HW2006 p.102, factors versus printed discrete forwards4.55e-5 rate maximum difference≤5e-5 rate, half printed precision
Same example, B instantaneous forwards on (0,30]Minimum 0.0087 rate; recovered discrete-forward error 0Positive; interval recovery ≤1e-14 rate
Paper example attributed to p.1079.09e-6 rate printed-forward difference; minimum 0.0366 rate; interval error 0Same precision/recovery thresholds
B average-forward recovery, each interval, midpoint integration with 2,000 steps6.26e-10 rate maximum≤1e-7 rate; numerical quadrature check
B minimum instantaneous forward, curve of recordApproximately 0.039 rate>0; differs from Act/360 overnight-forward quote
B continuity, either side of each node at 1e-9 years6.06e-11 rate maximum jump≤1e-6 rate
B intervals breaking local monotonicity0 intervals≤0
Flat 4% curve priced into deposits/OIS and calibrated backA 9.07e-11 bp; B 5.97e-12 bp maximum zero error≤1e-6 bp, monthly grid through 30Y
Separately written OIS par formula versus QuantLib helper on A2.08e-13 bp maximum≤1e-6 bp; common dates
B valued by QuantLib swap engine via daily business-day DFs1.27e-11 bp maximum input par error≤1e-4 bp; log-linear interpolation between those dates
B interpolation versus QuantLib (0,1), same nodes/discrete forwards3.47e-13 bp maximum forward difference≤1e-6 bp; collar inactive on this input
Anchor assumed versus subsequently realized fixing, 2026-09-18 and 2026-09-210 bp maximumExact retained match; ex-post check only

Source: CHECKS, checks entries by full check name; verify.py, paper_examples, properties, two_implementations, repricing. Rounded measurements are supplied by verify.md.

The developer uses the p.102 example's capitalisation factors because the brief reports a printed 4Y yield of 4.40% inconsistent with the factor 1.22140276 and forward, which imply 5.00%. Choosing the printed yield would fail the retained check; the underlying paper-page interpretation has not been established from a paper copy in this evidence review. Thus this is evidence of an implemented example check with an explicit developer interpretation, not independent confirmation of the paper's alleged misprint. Developer tolerances reflect rounding, half printed precision or the numerical approximations used; tighter or looser criteria were possible and are not institutionally validated. [BRIEF, Smaller choices—Tests; CHECKS, paper-example entries; HW-CODE; VERIFY, paper_examples.]

7.2 Separately written implementation comparison

Table 7. Method A only: retained implementation agreement, as-of 2026-09-18. The grid is exactly 7,482 SOFR-business-day observations from 2026-09-18 through 2056-09-26 inclusive.

Implementations comparedMaximum absolute DF difference (dimensionless)Mean absolute DF difference (dimensionless)
QuantLib A versus hagan_west.py log-linear bootstrap1.925126724700e-131.917074862633e-14

Source: IMPL, summary, implementation-comparison.csv, and summarize_implementations.py. The mean averages magnitudes; it is not a signed mean. Both share quotes, fixing, schedules and financial conventions.

This checks two implementations of A, and its agreement is far smaller than the A-versus-B method disagreement. It does not cover B as a full separately scheduled implementation, calendar correctness, data truth or an institution-specific benchmark. The interpolation-only B comparison feeds the same nodes to both algorithms and the collar is inactive; the brief's account that QuantLib's positivity option floors endpoints rather than applying the selected interior collar remains a source-code attribution, not a proof for other regimes. [IMPL, limits; CHECKS, B interpolation entry; BRIEF, Worked example.]

7.3 Pricing outside the bootstrap input set

Define a signed residual as close-adjusted print rate minus curve par rate, in bp. A negative value means the curve rate is above the print estimate. Absolute residuals remove that direction; the sign of ( |r_A|-|r_B| ) indicates which method is closer. The retained 983 rows comprise 523 spot-start prints at used input tenors, 140 spot-start prints at other maturities, and 320 forward-start prints. Only the last two cohorts, 460 rows, are held out of the bootstrap. They still share the fitted intraday adjustment; this is not independent licensed benchmark validation. [CHECKS, out_of_sample, paired_comparison; RESIDUALS, group and residual columns; VERIFY, out_of_sample.]

The historical combined held-out upper-middle absolute residual is 0.459942 bp for A and 0.404662 bp for B (about 0.460 and 0.405 bp), each below the selected 1 bp median-absolute criterion. The statistic sorts 460 magnitudes and selects zero-based index 230 rather than averaging the two center observations. Ordinary two-center medians computed from the same rows are 0.458535 and 0.404222 bp; this convention difference does not affect the threshold finding. The criterion was chosen by the developer because adjusted within-tenor IQRs were smaller than 1 bp, not derived from independent loss or execution-cost evidence. [VERIFY, med_a, med_b; CHECKS, held-out check; RESIDUALS; BRIEF, smaller testing choices.]

Table 8. Historical signed residual summaries, as-of 2026-09-18. Residual = adjusted print minus model par rate (bp), except the explicitly unadjusted late row. All numeric medians/quartiles use verify.py’s nearest-index rule.

Printsn (count)A median (bp)A p25 / p75 (bp)A within 1 bp (%)B median (bp)B p25 / p75 (bp)B within 1 bp (%)
spot start, input tenor523+0.00-0.28 / +0.2491%+0.00-0.28 / +0.2591%
spot start, other maturity140-0.21-0.69 / +0.1776%-0.18-0.51 / +0.1486%
forward start320-0.15-0.74 / +0.2479%-0.17-0.77 / +0.1678%
all983-0.04-0.49 / +0.2485%-0.04-0.45 / +0.2186%
held out, last two hours, unadjusted49-0.76-1.27 / +0.0255%-0.47-1.21 / +0.0459%

Source: CHECKS, out_of_sample, verify.md; RESIDUALS; verify.py stats selects sorted index int(p*(n-1)+0.5). The input-tenor and all-print rows are descriptive, not held-out populations.

The 49 held-out prints in the last two traded New York hours are additionally compared at their unadjusted rates, with median signed residual −0.76 bp for A and −0.47 bp for B. Because the close adjustment is at most 0.2 bp there, this provides a limited robustness view not driven by applying the intraday adjustment to the observed print. The small sample remains from the same day, and rates used to calibrate the curves were still derived with the adjustment. Last-hour-only or last-three-hour choices were possible; the former would be thinner and the latter admit larger adjustment. [CHECKS, late row; VERIFY, LATE_HOUR=15; BRIEF, Late-print row.]

Table 9. Historical paired comparisons, as-of 2026-09-18, separated by cohort and Act/365F years from as-of to expiration. Buckets are (0,1], (1,10], (10,last node], and (last node,99] years; “under 1Y” includes exactly 1Y in the code. P-values are dimensionless and two-sided.

Printsn (count)B closer (count)A closer (count)Sign-test p (two-sided)Median of abs(A) minus abs(B) (bp)Within 1 bp: A (count)Within 1 bp: B (count)
spot start, other maturity, under 1Y4130110.004+0.2772334
spot start, other maturity, 1Y to 10Y7037330.720+0.0036364
spot start, other maturity, 10Y to the last node2811170.345-0.0412123
spot start, other maturity, beyond the last node1101.000+3.66800
forward start, under 1Y2711150.557-0.0002320
forward start, 1Y to 10Y172101700.022+0.001138135
forward start, 10Y to the last node9660360.018+0.0387071
forward start, beyond the last node251870.043+0.0822222
all held-out prints460269189<0.001+0.007360369
spot start, other maturity, under 1Y, one per expiration date221660.052+0.2411419
spot start, other maturity, under 1Y, raw rates41356<0.001+0.3531117
spot start, other maturity, 6M to 1Y (exploratory)28244<0.001+0.8041326

Source: CHECKS, paired_comparison; verify.py, paired, bucket selection and robustness rows. Positive median of absolute A minus absolute B favors B on that magnitude statistic. Even-count medians select the upper middle. The final three rows are separate robustness/exploratory populations, not added to the eight primary buckets.

B is closer on 30 of 41 noninput spot maturities under one year and A on 11, with historical median absolute-residual difference +0.277 bp. Those trades span 22 expiration dates: treating each date as one observation yields 16 versus 6 and two-sided sign-test p=0.052, substantially weaker than the trade-level p=0.004. On raw rates B is closer on 35 of 41, but fewer observations are within 1 bp for either curve. The 6M–1Y group gives B 24 of 28 and median difference +0.804 bp; it was selected after seeing the results and is exploratory. It coincides with the missing 9M calibration tenor, consistent with a curvature benefit in that gap rather than a universal advantage. [CHECKS, specified paired rows; BRIEF, choice 1.]

The other multi-print maturity groups have median differences from −0.041 to +0.082 bp. All held-out counts of B/A closer are 269/189 with two ties under the code's (10^{-9}) bp comparison tolerance; aggregate median difference is only +0.007 bp. The sign test measures which is closer, not how much; eight primary buckets and repeated expiration dates weaken a simple significance interpretation. A paired t-test or Wilcoxon test was an alternative, not a retained result. [CHECKS, paired comparison; VERIFY, paired; BRIEF, Paired sign test.]

Table 10. Descriptive end-date distance bins, as-of 2026-09-18. All residual statistics are absolute residuals in bp and counts are prints; the two held-out cohorts remain separate.

CohortEnd-date distancePrints (count)A median absolute residual (bp)A IQR (bp)B median absolute residual (bp)B IQR (bp)
spot start, other maturity0–30 days370.4070.4640.2920.373
spot start, other maturity31–90 days720.5480.9140.3640.602
spot start, other maturity>90 days310.5640.4770.3540.253
forward start0–30 days900.5780.8200.5980.841
forward start31–90 days1630.4280.7040.3880.732
forward start>90 days670.4430.5600.3660.475

Source: DISTANCE, residual-distance.json summary, residual-distance.md, historically calculated by summarize_residuals.py from RESIDUALS and NODES. New arithmetic inspection of those frozen rows reproduces these medians and IQRs; no financial model was rerun.

Distance is the absolute number of calendar days between a print's expiration and the nearest used OIS payment pillar; O/N and T/N are excluded. Bins are 0–30 inclusive, 31–90 inclusive, and greater than 90. Interquartile range (IQR) is the 75th percentile minus the 25th of absolute residuals using inclusive linear interpolation of empirical order statistics. These descriptive bins preserve spot and forward starts separately and are not the same intervals as the maturity buckets. In particular, B's median is higher in the forward-start 0–30-day bin despite its lower aggregate median. Nearness of an expiration does not represent start-date differences, financial risk, independent observations or generalization. [DISTANCE, distance_definition, quartiles, summary; summarize_residuals.py, summarize.]

7.4 Sensitivity, locality and extrapolation

Table 11. Historical convention perturbations versus the base curve, as-of 2026-09-18, maximum absolute DF change on the 361-date monthly grid (dimensionless). Each row rebuilds with the specified alternative convention in the retained calculation.

Change versus baseA maximum absolute DF changeB maximum absolute DF change
Payment lag 0 rather than 2 business days1.32579e-54.79181e-6
Quarterly rather than annual payments0.006616210.00661321
Fixed leg interpreted Act/365F rather than Act/3600.005000700.00500142
Overnight anchor raised 1 bp1.10710e-61.31062e-6

Source: RESULTS, convention_sensitivities; BOOT, convention variants. These are scenario sensitivities to changed assumptions, not evidence that the alternative convention is correct or a market risk distribution.

The schedule and day-count effects exceed the observed A/B maximum on this grid, so comparing interpolators while assuming schedules correct can miss a larger error source. Payment lag and annual-versus-quarterly schedules were chosen as convention sensitivities because the developer considered them insufficiently fixed by prints; roll convention and calendar variants were not measured. The Act/365F fixed-leg sensitivity is implemented by scaling fixed rates by 365/360 in otherwise Act/360 instruments. [BOOT, act365, qtr, lag0; BRIEF, Assumptions and Convention sensitivities.]

Historical 5Y quote-bump response

Figure 3. As-of 2026-09-18 response of overnight forwards, bumped minus base (bp), to +1 bp in the 5Y OIS quote, against years from as-of. Frozen fig_bump_5y.png, bootstrap.py, bump_5y_forward_change.csv. The inclusive inside window uses actual 4Y/6Y payment nodes 2030-09-25 and 2032-09-24. B's larger outside response demonstrates less locality on this perturbation; it does not define a full risk-system bump policy.

Historical cash-flow sensitivity ladder

Figure 4. As-of 2026-09-18 PV change (USD), bumped minus base, for USD 100 million paid 2031-03-24 (4.5Y from spot), under a separate +1 bp bump to each of twenty OIS inputs. Frozen fig_delta_ladder.png, bootstrap.py, delta_ladder_4p5y.csv. Signed bars are PV changes, not hedge notionals. Section 5's outside share sums their absolute magnitudes, so offsetting bars are not netted.

The unbumped cash-flow DFs are 0.81397156 (A) and 0.81397425 (B), giving A-minus-B PV −USD 269.46 from full-precision results. Beyond 30Y the extrapolated 35Y overnight forwards are 4.2248% and 3.9957%; at the last node the displayed jump is 0.00 bp for both, with A's retained numerical difference about (8.0\times10^{-10}) bp. Rounded zero is not exact arithmetic identity. Continuity there says nothing about whether the continued level is supported by market data. [RESULTS, off_node, extrapolation, forward_smoothness.]

8. Limitations and compensating controls

Every control below is a fictional proposed design from HER-scenario-1, with no operating-effectiveness evidence. A control's existence in the dossier is not proof that it operates. The proposed responses withhold or restrict use and record exceptions; they do not retrospectively authorize the historical model. [INST, Proposed controls and monitoring thresholds.]

Table 12. Reliance limitations, proposed fictional responses and residual gaps for the 2026-09-18 demonstration.

Limitation and consequenceSupplied proposed control and ownerResidual limitation / effectiveness
Calibration/solver failure can prevent reliable curve constructionC-01: every input ≤0.01 bp; developer holds/diagnoses breach, coordinator considers reassessmentOne successful snapshot is no convergence guarantee; no operating evidence
Thin/noisy estimates, surviving off-market prints and unusual matched stubsC-02: ≥5 qualifying prints, IQR ≤2 bp; Market Data Controls Lead marks unsupported tenor unavailableCount/dispersion rule does not certify a par print or stale-data tolerance
Derived public execution medians are mistaken for a licensed closeC-03: label estimates and require licensed benchmark before production; model ownerNo executable benchmark, feed entitlement or reconciliation record
Pricing outside inputs shares close adjustment and exploratory selectionC-04: median absolute residual ≤1 bp with separate spot/forward summaries; developer investigates breachPassing cannot remove common adjustment, one-date dependence or multiplicity
Sparse 20Y–30Y input, propagated end-rule shapeC-05: model owner reviews shape, concentration and A/B disagreement each future candidateNo quantitative production exposure limit or independently observed long-end shape
Beyond-node values rely solely on extrapolationC-06: label sandbox extrapolation, prohibit proposed production beyond node pending policy; model ownerNo actual enforcement or authorized long-rate assumption
B sensitivity spillover and partial locality testC-07: developer reviews 5Y bump and full 4.5Y ladder, proposes multi-date all-input campaignOne cash flow and one forward-bump window do not cover a portfolio
One positive-rate date; negative-rate and stressed regimes untestedC-08: stop extending this snapshot's claims to negative rates; model owner commissions separate studyNo stress evidence, regime threshold or negative-rate admissibility assessment
Shared calendar, payment and accrual defectsC-09: coordinator obtains separate schedule/calendar reconciliationBoth methods may agree on wrong dates; holiday-list equivalence unverified
Code, data transformation, convention or library changesC-10: developer retains immutable change record and impact assessmentNo actual release or recovery evidence
Document/evidence driftC-11: coordinator matches document, manifest and assessment hashesA hash does not itself verify claims or transfer an assessment to changed bytes

Source: INST, C-01–C-11; model limitations in BRIEF choices and Assumptions; numerical evidence in Sections 5 and 7.

Central-bank meeting and year-end event steps are excluded. No dedicated proposed event-step control is supplied; reliance where those discontinuities matter is outside scope. Multi-curve, alternative collateral and other-currency uses are also outside scope rather than compensated by a demonstrated control. The hourly close model ignores multiple intraday factors and finer-time variation; C-03's proposed data replacement and C-04's residual review only partly address that issue. No historical control-effectiveness record is supplied for any of these risks. [BRIEF, Scope and exclusions, choice 2; INST, controls and data lineage.]

Monitoring is proposed at each candidate build for C-01–C-04 and C-11, quarterly for limitations/dependencies, and on convention, data, model or regime changes. Escalation records the exception and withholds the proposed use. A missing required input, stale feed input or incompatible convention holds a candidate; a feed-specific service agreement and actual stale-quote tolerance remain unspecified. A changed snapshot needs new calibration and assessment of eligibility, not automatic reuse of the historical passes. [INST, Data lineage and proposed daily process; Proposed controls and monitoring thresholds.]

[INSTITUTIONAL GAP: Actual monitoring implementation, breach and resolution records, control effectiveness and real operational ownership are unavailable.]

[INSTITUTIONAL GAP: Actual fixed-close snapshot policy, feed-specific service agreement and stale-quote tolerances are unavailable.]

[INSTITUTIONAL GAP: Actual extrapolation authorization and production policy beyond the last node are unavailable.]

[INSTITUTIONAL GAP: The full risk-system bump methodology and approved exposure limits are unavailable.]

9. Assumptions register

Table 13. Assumptions behind the historical 2026-09-18 curve and quote derivation. Monitoring references are fictional proposed controls, not observed operation.

AssumptionSupplied reason and evidenceConsequence if falseMonitoring or unresolved work
SOFR is both projection and discount rate for the covered USD cash flowsScope choice, BRIEF 6; implemented par formulaWrong collateral/basis treatmentEnforce stated scope; actual collateral/use inventory absent
Last known 3.85% fixing holds to spotPublished anchor; ex-post retained next fixings match, CHECKS anchor entryFront-end DFs change; +1 bp sensitivity in Table 11C-03 data replacement/reconciliation; real fixing availability policy absent
A004 denotes Actual360 for selected fixed legsBRIEF attributes definition to CFTC Appendix C p.55; 4,211 coded trades in QUOTESUp to about 0.005 DF shift under alternative in retained sensitivityC-09 independently reconcile conventions; primary specification claim unchecked here
Both legs follow annual/single-payment schedulesReported frequency filters, BRIEF and QUOTESQuarterly sensitivity about 0.0066 DF; cash-flow model differsC-02 eligibility; C-09 schedule reconciliation
Two-business-day payment lag is suitableBRIEF attribution to ARRC p.17; implemented BOOT helper settingTable 11 lag sensitivity; par cancellation differs by scheduleC-09; actual production convention evidence absent
QuantLib SOFR calendar matches intended business daysShared helper convention; developer cites the SIFMA-determined Treasury repo calendar and QuantLib implementation; direct NY Fed holiday-list use was the alternativeBoth curves can misdate the same accrual/paymentsC-09 separate holiday/calendar reconstruction; not performed
Non-package, no-upfront filtered fixed rates are suitable par observationsDeveloper economic reasoning and upfront-rate-rounding evidenceResidual contamination and biased quote mediansC-02/C-03; 20 off-market matched prints remain
One common hourly factor times bounded loading captures tenor driftPath and loading tables; long-tenor fitted loadings 0.97–1.08Biased close levels and shared errors in held-out comparisonC-03/C-04; leave-one-tenor-out tests path tenors only
Sparse short-tenor loadings may be interpolated and forwards use expiration loadingAt least eight prints/five hours requirement; simple forward-start ruleLevel/move not separable, start/length variation ignoredSeparate loading/forward-start analysis not supplied; C-03 replacement proposed
Five prints and IQR ≤2 bp make a usable estimateDeveloper eligibility judgment; no IQR rejection this dateThin median unstable despite rule, long-end concentrationC-02/C-05; no sampling-error guarantee
Chosen interpolation is acceptable between observationsB shape rationale versus A; Table 3Off-node prices and sensitivities depend on unsupported shapeC-05/C-07; broader competitor, date and risk tests unresolved
Positive discrete forwards are the relevant regime for B's collarDeveloper collar rationale; zero binding nodes historicallyNegative-rate shape behavior not establishedC-08 separate study before extending conclusions
Final forward can continue beyond the last nodeDeveloper's HW2006 attribution; explicit integral codeExtrapolated DFs differ and lack quote supportC-06; actual authorization absent

Source: BRIEF, Assumptions and named choices; QUOTES; RESULTS; BOOT; HW-CODE; INST. Neither a stated rationale nor a historical pass demonstrates that an assumption remains valid on another date.

10. Governance and institutional record

All facts in this section describe the fictional Harbor Example Research dossier. Inventory HER-QM-017 (simulated), revision sofr-snapshot-2026-09-18, is Tier 2 under a fictional policy because it is a material quantitative method limited to sandbox use with no production exposure. Actual institutional tiering would depend on real reliance, exposures and controls. The scenario status is proposed sandbox methodology awaiting documentation assessment; approved uses are none. Proposed consumers are notebook curve-research and report rates-methodology, with no actual integration. [INST, Inventory and intended use.]

Fictional Maya Chen represents the Rates Research Lead/model owner, Daniel Ortiz the Curve Research Analyst/developer, Priya Shah the Model Review Lead/review coordinator, and Elias Brooks the Market Data Controls Lead/monitoring owner. No review has been performed by Priya Shah in the scenario. The Research Model Committee is the accountable authorization role and its decision is pending. These names do not identify actual reviewers of this document. [INST, inventory role rows.]

Scenario change HER-CR-001 concerns the first methodology document from fixed September data; model code, filters and frozen numerical outputs are not amended. The proposed system is the fictional HER research sandbox. Version history begins with this newly created demo-v1 document dated 2026-10-12; there is no supplied prior document revision. No actual implementation ticket, vendor agreement, production release or recovery test exists in the supplied evidence. [INST, Implementation and change record.]

Open fictional findings are F-01 licensed benchmark missing (blocking production consideration), F-02 multi-date/stressed assessment absent, F-03 convention/calendar reconciliation not independent, F-04 controls have no operating evidence, and F-05 document assessment pending at dossier authoring. Closing them requires, respectively, identified benchmark/tolerance/discrepancy analysis; an authorized retained campaign and separate assessment; separately sourced calendar/schedule work; real control ownership and performance records; and a separate assessment of the exact final document hash. A document readiness self-check cannot retrospectively close findings on behalf of fictional people. [INST, Open findings and disposition.]

The sign-off block is not signed. Approval conditions are unknown because the scenario committee has made no decision; resolving F-01 through F-04 and separately assessing the document are proposed conditions for consideration, not attached approval conditions. Exception handling means recording the breach, withholding the proposed use and escalating to the designated roles. Changing a tolerance to fit a result is not the supplied process. Actual institutional validation, authorization and any applicable regulatory judgment are separate from documentation readiness. [INST, Approval and required real-world gaps; Proposed controls; HOUSE, Institutional facts.]

[INSTITUTIONAL GAP: Actual institutional inventory ID, materiality tier and tier rationale are unavailable.]

[INSTITUTIONAL GAP: Actual internal market-data feed lineage, licenses, entitlements and reconciliation evidence are unavailable.]

[INSTITUTIONAL GAP: Actual model owner, developer, reviewer, committee authorization and role assignments are unavailable.]

[INSTITUTIONAL GAP: Real prior validation findings, disposition history and independently performed assessment are unavailable.]

[INSTITUTIONAL GAP: Actual approval decision and approval conditions are unavailable.]

[INSTITUTIONAL GAP: A real licensed benchmark curve, immutable snapshot, comparison tolerance and discrepancy analysis are unavailable.]

[INSTITUTIONAL GAP: Actual implementation/change ticket, production deployment record and recovery test are unavailable.]

[INSTITUTIONAL GAP: Real institutional signatures and sign-off evidence are unavailable.]

11. Third-party components

QuantLib 1.43 supplies A's bootstrap, SOFR calendar, deposit/OIS helpers, schedules and the comparison swap engine. The developer's B code supplies its own interpolation, integral and par calculation but consumes QuantLib's instrument dates. SciPy 1.18.1 solves the simultaneous nonlinear system. NumPy supports arrays; pandas handles trade transformation; statsmodels fits median regression; matplotlib renders historical figures. Versions in Section 6 are from the stage receipts and should not be replaced by current documentation defaults. [ENV, package fields; BOOT and HW-CODE imports and calls; DERIVE imports/path fit.]

The developer attributes B to Hagan and West (2008), the par relation and examples to Hagan and West (2006), broader multi-curve context to Ametrano and Bianchetti (2013), payment/compounding conventions to ARRC (2021), and historical futures/discounting context to CME (2020). These are external rationales recorded in the brief. Their papers were not acquired as answer sources for this document; titles and locators alone are not confirmation of contents. In particular the CME account is a historical planned transition, not evidence of eventual implementation or current practice, and no legal or supervisory applicability claim is made. [BRIEF, source-specific attributions; SOURCES, Original public sources.]

Shared dependency agreement is useful for finding coding errors but leaves shared data and schedule error unresolved. The retained default/paper-setting QuantLib variants illustrate that library settings and solver strategy matter. The developer's analytic integration _G, simultaneous calibration and selected interior collar are specific implementation choices, rather than an unmodified invocation of QuantLib's default interpolation. Copied developer code and authored evidence carry the bundle's MIT notice; third-party data and papers retain their own terms. [HW-CODE; RESULTS, variants; WE, license and scope paragraphs; LICENSE.]

12. References

Keys below identify the permitted public origins. Local copies under inputs/ preserve the actually retrieved bytes; public origins, not private repository paths, resolve substantive references. A key plus a named function, field, row or section in the text identifies the claimed relationship. All numerical outputs concern the 2026-09-18 snapshot unless explicitly identified as a synthetic/paper check; historical receipts are dated 2026-10-02.

External citations embedded in the developer's reasoning remain attributions to BRIEF, not independently checked paper claims: HW2008, §6 and §6.1, equations 22–34; HW2006, pp.92, 102, 107, 109, 124–126; ARRC2021, pp.5, 17, 31, 35; CFTC historical specification, Appendix C p.55; CME August 2020 methodology, §§1, 1.3, 2.1; AB2013 abstract; DTCC PPD guide p.7; and QuantLib 1.43 convex-monotone implementation. Source-of-record origins for data provenance are New York Fed SOFR and the original DTCC 2026-09-18 archive; the archive was not reacquired or reconstructed.

SOFR data republication notice

The SOFR data is subject to the Terms of Use posted at newyorkfed.org. The New York Fed is not responsible for publication of the SOFR data by OpenProse, does not sanction or endorse any particular republication, and has no liability for your use.

OpenProse is not affiliated with the New York Fed. The New York Fed does not sanction, endorse, or recommend any products or services offered by OpenProse.

reviews.md

Download raw Markdown
Sections in reviews.md

Documentation supporting records — demo-v1

Date: 2026-10-12. Source revision: 01ae3bdac6f61ecbabcd72e0116ebb2860e93157; input as-of: 2026-09-18; fictional dossier: HER-scenario-1. This is executor readiness work, not independent assessment or institutional validation. The selected OpenProse agreement is release 0.4.6-rc.1. Scope: inspect frozen evidence and create documentation; no financial-model script was executed.

Record 1 — Section plan and requirement mapping

This final section plan maps content obligations to concrete locations. Requirement IDs remain in this supporting record. “Met” means the documentary obligation is satisfied at the specified location; it does not establish that missing actual institutional evidence has been supplied. The individual judgments below are the executor's assessment of the final artifact. Sections and table numbers are locators in document.md.

RequirementStatusDocument/report locatorEvidence and remaining work
R-01MetFront matter; §1 first two paragraphsPlain-language discounting and projection, fictional commission and decision; BRIEF Model, INST Inventory
R-02Met§§1–2Historical demonstration, proposed sandbox, no approved use; products/currency/collateral/horizons and exclusions distinct
R-03Met§3.1–3.2Deposit and lagged OIS equations, curve/forward relations, interpolation/solution and exact date conventions; source functions cited
R-04Met§4.1–4.2, Tables 1–2Real fixing, public prints, derived estimates and fictional facts separated; timing, unit, filters, transformations and limits
R-05Met§7.1, §7.4, Tables 5–6 and 11Historical developmental checks, all repricing rows, convention perturbations; current arithmetic distinguished
R-06Met§7.2–7.3, Tables 7–10A implementation check separate from method comparison; spot/forward cohorts, residual signs and common adjustment explicit; no licensed benchmark
R-07Met§§5.1, 7.4, 8–9One date, sparse long end, locality, extrapolation, event steps, conventions and stress limitations
R-08Met§8, Table 12 and paragraph after tableEach material limitation linked to proposed control or explicit absent/dedicated-control gap; no effectiveness assertion
R-09Met§9, Table 13Construction and quote assumptions with reason/evidence, consequence and monitoring/unresolved work
R-10Met§8 Table 12 and cadence paragraph; §10 exception processThresholds, owners, candidate/quarterly/event cadence and hold/review triggers from fictional dossier
R-11Met§10 and §8 gap markersFictional inventory/tier/roles/change/findings/sign-off; actual institutional facts visibly unavailable
R-12Met§§6 and 11Named scripts, historical versions and shared schedule/data dependence; customized B and comparison limitations
R-13Met§12 plus locators throughoutEvery citation key expanded to public origin; no private repository used as an answer source
R-20Met§§3–5.3, 7.1–7.4, 9; Record 2 belowAll seven principal choices and 27 smaller entries preserved with reasons/alternatives/limits; unspecified alternatives marked
R-21Met§5.1 opening equation/Table 3; §7.3–7.4Single-cash-flow maximum, signs and units; smoother-forward versus wider-risk tradeoff; no “profit” inference
R-30Met§6, Table 4; §12 source linksSource identities and historical receipts; full offline raw-data reproduction explicitly unavailable
R-31MetCaptions/source lines for Tables 1–13 plus 3a; Figures 1–4Dated calculation identities, units and populations; Table 5 current arithmetic and Table 10 arithmetic confirmation labeled
R-40MetClaim locators throughout; Record 3Material relationships checked against exact sources and code; attribution-only external claims separated; no claim that unchecked papers were read
R-41Met§11 second paragraph; §12 external references; Record 3 external statusOnly registered bundle evidence used; unavailable/unretrieved primary contents not asserted as independently established
R-50MetFront matter; §§2, 8, 10 (14 gap markers)Fictional dossier clearly simulated; every selected actual institutional slot unavailable or covered by actual new document history
R-60MetFront matter status; §§1, 10; Record 4Readiness, self-check, independent assessment and actual authorization kept separate
R-61MetFront matter blockquoteExact house disclaimer retained; applies to extracts too
R-62MetThis table; agreement/house mapping below; Record 4Each requirement separately assessed; unresolved substantive real-world evidence listed without treating disclosure as supply

Agreement and house requirements beyond the base IDs

Selected obligationStatus and exact homeRemaining substantive work
Kernel: selected identity, nested adoption and origin retentionMet; result.md, input-manifest.json; six pinned definitions read and declared hashes matchedRelease is experimental; no general conformance certification
Documentation contract: complete methodology rather than decision noteMet; all twelve numbered sections, about 7,195 words excluding table rows/reference list at draft checkIndependent content assessment still required
Documentation contract: section plan, choice register, citation audit, readiness and resultMet; four clearly separated records here plus result.mdNo implication of independent assessment
Model-description contract: purpose, inputs/outputs, method, assumptions/limits and revisionMet; front matter and §§1–4, 8–9Actual deployment facts unavailable and marked
Numerical-evidence contract: exact populations, intervals, units, comparison baseline, precision and interpretationMet; §§5 and 7, especially Table 7 and §7.3 statistical conventionsRaw-source reproduction outside scope; untested regimes remain unknown
Claim-evidence contract: relationship checked, missing/conflicting claims visibleMet; Record 3 and source-located documentExternal paper contents unchecked; used only as attributed developer rationale
Institutional-facts contract: simulated facts and exact missing-fact markerMet; §§2, 8, 10Actual institutional inventory, feeds, exposures, roles, policies, benchmark, assessment and signatures remain unavailable
House: exact title/version/date/status/inventory and three-sentence conclusionMet; front matterNone for documentation presentation
House: twelve exact numbered ## headingsMet; §§1–12None
House: captions, units, dates, calculation identities, local figuresMet; all tables and Figures 1–4Plots are retained historical images, not newly generated
House: all 22 input errors and 0.01 bp criterionMet; Table 5, current frozen-column arithmeticThis is not a fresh calibration run
House: ≤1 bp held-out median criterion; exact A implementation grid and max/mean; distance binsMet; §7.2–7.3, Tables 7–10Criterion passage does not give production acceptance
House: paper checks, round trip, sensitivities, continuity, collar, extrapolation, locality and failed QuantLib variantMet; §§5.2, 7.1, 7.4Primary paper interpretation and solver generality are not independently established
House: complete republication notice and nonaffiliationMet; §12 final subsectionTerms linked; no external legal conclusion offered
Program: saved document/reviews/result, local figures and input manifestMet; result.md artifact tableActual institutional authorization remains separate
Program: no raw reconstruction, model rerun, installs, source changes, publication or approvalMet; result execution/effects recordNo such effect observed or claimed

Record 2 — Modeling choice register

Reason means the developer's stated rationale. A brief citation establishes that the developer made that choice; it does not independently prove the cited paper's contents or establish a theorem. All BRIEF locators refer to inputs/model-brief.md with public origin preserved in the manifest. “No alternative stated” is an explicit absence, not an invented rationale.

ID / choiceSupplied reasonAlternatives consideredLimitation / evidenceDocument locator
P01 Monotone-convex unameliorated B, collar, simultaneous fitForward projection shape; smaller short broken-date benefit; developer attributes recommendation to HW2008A raw/log-linear; QuantLib defaults and paper-setting bootstrap; cubic splinesLess local; sparse long-end dependence; default variant differs, paper-setting solver fails, cubic not built. BRIEF choice 1; RESULTS variants/shape/locality; CHECKS paired rows§§3.2, 5.1–5.2, 7
P02 Close-adjusted median printsRemove intraday drift from the available free/date-specific public source; median robustnessRaw all-day or last-hours medians; licensed vendor/clearing closeOne factor, interpolated loadings, execution estimates, common held-out adjustment; sole-source assertion is developer rationale. BRIEF 2; QUOTES§4.2, §5.3
P03 Eligible par-print filters, ≥5 prints and IQR ≤2 bpAlign fixed rate with instrument par rate; package/upfront/schedule differences matterInclude packages, convert other schedules, count floor 10Missing 9M/25Y; retained off-market prints; widest 20Y–30Y gap. BRIEF 3; QUOTES filter counts§4.1, §5.2–5.3
P04 Last-known-fixing O/N and T/NPin as-of-to-spot from a published available inputStart at spot; use later published as-of fixingAssumes four-day constant fixing; ex-post match and small anchor sensitivity don't prove future behavior. BRIEF 4; FIXING§§3.1, 5.2, 7.1, 9
P05 OIS only, no futuresOIS span to 30Y from one retained report; missing futures data and convexity complexityShort-end futures, developer's CME exampleLimited front-end detail. BRIEF 5; external CME/HW assertion not independently checked§§2, 5.2
P06 Single curveDeliberate scope; developer cites multi-curve literature for broader settingMulti-curve frameworkSOFR projection only. BRIEF 6§§1–3, 5.2, 9
P07 Flat terminal instantaneous forwardDeveloper's HW2006 p.109 attribution; continuous last-node extensionLong-rate assumption; institutional extrapolation policyNo quote after last node, B's end rule determines held level; policy missing. BRIEF 7; RESULTS extrapolation§§3.2, 5.2, 7.4, 8
C01 B positivity collarDeveloper states positivity for positive discrete forwardsNo collar, builtCan flatten near nodes; no binding here; negative regime unassessed. BRIEF Smaller choices/Construction; RESULTS collar/variant§§3.2, 5.1–5.2, 9
C02 Simultaneous SciPy hybrid Powell systemB depends on neighboring intervals; sequential solver may failIterate nodewise solves to fixed pointNo convergence proof; loud residual failure >1e-11 rate. BRIEF Construction; HW-CODE bootstrap§3.2, §5.2
C03 A as transparent comparisonDeveloper attributes mistake-finding comparison recommendation to HW2008 p.73QuantLib default also measured; cubic not builtA is not demonstrated best competitor. BRIEF Construction§5.2
C04 Common QuantLib instrument datesConditional comparison isolates interpolationSeparate schedule code for BShared schedule defect remains; pricer agreement checks valuation not dates. BRIEF Construction; BOOT hw_instruments§§3.1, 5.2, 7.2, 8
C05 Last-payment-date nodesKeep default helper pillar and common node setFinal accrual-end nodeQuote does not independently pin final lag days; 1M node rates differ. BRIEF Construction; NODES§3.1, §5.2
C06 Act/365F time, continuous zerosDeveloper's paper notation/common neutral time rationaleAct/360 timeDescriptive rates change with convention, DFs do not. BRIEF Construction§3.1, §5.2
Q01 Median regressionMatch median quote treatment of off-market printsLeast squares; trimmed least squaresNo least-squares comparison supplied. BRIEF Close adjustment; DERIVE QuantReg§4.2, Table 3a
Q02 Path ≥2Y, loading oneLong-tenor fitted loadings near one; short tenors moved lessSeparate loading each tenorIgnores 0.97–1.08 movement differences. BRIEF Close adjustment; QUOTES loadings§4.2, Table 3a
Q03 ≥8 prints in ≥5 hours to fit loadingNeed time coverage to separate level from movementFit every tenor2M loading interpolated. BRIEF Close adjustment§4.2, Table 3a
Q04 Loading clipped to [0,1]Developer views negative or above-long loading as noise on this dayUnconstrainedFitted 1M −0.04 replaced by zero. BRIEF Close adjustment; QUOTES§4.2, Table 3a
Q05 Last traded hour closeLatest path-tenor observationsFixed 15:00 closeHour 16 is not a published fixing. BRIEF Close adjustment§4.2, Table 3a
Q06 Forward-start expiration loadingSimple rule without forward-start modelDepend on start and length1Y starting in 1Y treated like 2Y. BRIEF Close adjustment§4.2, Table 3a
S01 Four-calendar-day tenor matchingAbsorb weekend/holiday adjustmentsExact-date matching; recompute adjusted maturityUnusual near-tenor stub can match. BRIEF Print selection§4.1, §5.2
S02 New York execution dayAlign close rather than UTC report dateReport UTC dayEvening print still in as-of date. BRIEF Print selection; DERIVE ts_ny§4.1, §5.2
S03 Adjusted IQR ≤2 bpWide spread signals less reliable median given tight liquid tenorsNo dispersion screenNo tenor excluded by dispersion this date; 9M/25Y fail counts. BRIEF Print selection; QUOTES§4.1, §5.2
S04 Keep off-market printsAvoid tuning a removal rule; median limits influenceDrop beyond 5 bpThin tenor more exposed; removal maximum quote movement 0.124 bp. BRIEF Print selection§4.1, §5.2
S05 A004 onlyInstruments accrue Act/360Convert other codesExcludes 47 of 4,258 rather than converting; CFTC definition unverified externally. BRIEF Print selection; QUOTES§4.1, §5.2, §9
T01 Location of B bump spilloverNeighboring-node formula transmits 5Y bump through 4Y into 3Y–4Y intervalNo distinct alternative stated; explanatory mechanismLargest outside-window response just after 3Y; conditional on this bump. BRIEF Tests; HW-CODE node formula§5.1
T02 5Y +1 bp window 4Y–6Y; 4.5Y cash flowMid-curve, 76 prints; developer attributes bump/cashflow examples to HW papersAll-input bump/stability normOne forward bump and one cash flow; 10Y has 99 prints. BRIEF Tests; QUOTES§5.1, §5.3, §7.4
T03 Close-adjusted outside-input median absolute residual ≤1 bpTolerance exceeds observed adjusted IQRsMaturity-specific toleranceJudgment, not derived; common adjustment. BRIEF Tests§5.3, §7.3
T04 Late raw-print rowReduce adjustment dependenceLast hour only; last three hoursOnly 49 observations; base curves still adjusted. BRIEF Tests; VERIFY LATE_HOUR§7.3
T05 Paired sign test by bucketCompare closeness on same prints without residual-size modelPaired t-test; WilcoxonCounts direction, not magnitude; multiplicity and repeated expirations. BRIEF Tests§5.3, §7.3
T06 Worst monthly-date USD 100m PVExpress economic disagreement in currency unitsActual portfolio PV differenceSingle cash flow at worst date; no portfolio supplied. BRIEF Tests; RESULTS DF difference§5.1, §5.3
T07 Leave-one-tenor-outTest influence of own prints on fitted pathCross-validation across hoursPath tenors only, not fitted short loadings. BRIEF Tests; QUOTES leave-out§4.2, §5.3
T08 Numerical check tolerancesRounding, printed precision, midpoint approximation, near-node continuity and daily-grid approximation set scalesTighter/looserDeveloper choices, not institutionally validated; specific units in Table 6. BRIEF Tests; CHECKS§5.3, §7.1
T09 p.102 capitalisation factorsDeveloper reads factor/forward as consistent and yield as a misprintPrinted yield would failPrimary page image interpretation unchecked; report as developer account. BRIEF Tests; VERIFY paper_examples§7.1
T10 Payment lag zero, quarterly convention sensitivitiesTwo conventions developer considered incompletely fixed by printsRoll/calendar sensitivitiesOther convention variants not measured. BRIEF Tests; RESULTS convention_sensitivities§7.4

Record 3 — Citation audit

The audit below checks material relationships against the specified inputs, rather than treating a citation's presence as support. “Supported” means the particular asserted relationship is supported within the specified source scope. It does not mean the underlying market, fictional institution or external paper has been independently validated. “Unchecked” is reserved for claims whose original external source was not read; those claims appear in the document only as attributed developer statements. “Unavailable” applies to required actual institutional or original raw inputs not supplied. No material claim is marked supported merely because a matching number occurs somewhere.

A. Model, data, choices and numerical relationships

Audit ID / document locatorMaterial assertion checkedSource locator inspected and actual checkStatus / scope
A01 Front matter, §1One curve discounts USD and projects compounded SOFR; B is developer preferenceBRIEF Model and choice 1; HW-CODE Ois/ois_par_rate matches telescoping relationSupported as implemented scope and developer preference
A02 Front matter, §5.1USD 227,458.20 is worst single-payment disagreement, not profitRESULTS max_abs ×100,000,000 =227458.19731463946; GRID maximum-date row has A>B; checked arithmetic in checks.jsonSupported; JSON precision used, CSV alone insufficient for cents
A03 §§1–2Fictional sandbox, no approved use, no real portfolioINST Inventory rows and opening disclaimer read; USD100m explicitly unit exposureSupported only as fictional scenario and absence in supplied evidence
A04 §2Monthly end 2056-09-18 differs from 30Y node 2056-09-26GRID last row, NODES 30Y, BOOT monthly constructionSupported; avoids conflating grids
A05 §3.1Deposit and payment-lag OIS relations, both day-count basesHW-CODE Deposit/Ois/ois_par_rate and BOOT T/ql_helpers/hw_instruments readSupported implemented equations; source-paper equivalence only attributed
A06 §3.1Known fixing 2026-09-17 3.85%, two deposits to spotFIXING named fields; BRIEF convention table; BOOT deposit helper valuesSupported frozen input identity; not new source-of-record fetch
A07 §3.11M node zero rates differ despite both fitting inputNODES 1M has 3.9407/3.9477%; par formula pay factor cancels for one periodSupported; not a claim that rounded DFs are equal
A08 §3.2A piecewise-flat forward and B neighbor-dependent sectors/integralHW-CODE LogLinearDiscount, MonotoneConvex, _sector/_g/_G inspected directlySupported as code account, not blanket theorem
A09 §3.2Solver tolerance and loud residual guard differ from house criterionHW-CODE root call: tol 1e-14, maxfev20000, guard1e-11; HOUSE .01bpSupported; dimensions kept separate
A10 §4.1 Tables 1–2Data categories, 23,563/4,258/663/529 counts and 523 used printsQUOTES filter paragraphs; table used counts and excluded 4+2; DERIVE eligibilitySupported retained derivation account; raw archive not checked
A11 §4.1Upfront rate-rounding denominators are 1,661 and 2,390, distinct from spot populationQUOTES paragraph: total4051, packages included, 26%/3%; document preserves denominatorSupported; no false filtering denominator
A12 §4.1Other day-count code count47, outliers20, removal sensitivity.124bpQUOTES code counts sum to4258; A0044211; outlier paragraphSupported retained results; primary CFTC mapping separately unchecked
A13 §4.1Floor10 removes stated eight tenors, no dispersion exclusionsQUOTES count/IQR columns read across22 tenors; DERIVE eligibility both conditionsSupported; tenors9M/25Y fail count, not spread
A14 §4.2Adjustment sign, median fit and common long-tenor pathDERIVE close_adj = fixed − loading×path; QuantReg q=.5; QUOTES negative path to0Supported; “about7bp rise” not treated as monotonic
A15 §4.2/Table3aFitted/interpolated/clipped loading distinctions and limitsQUOTES loading rows; DERIVE loading_for, min-print/hour conditionsSupported; forward-start rule uses time to expiration
A16 §4.2IQR narrowing, raw 4Y inversion, .165bp leave-out maximumQUOTES full tenor and leave-out tables; 100×(4.6206−4.5612)=5.94bpSupported rounded description; in-sample caveat retained
A17 §5 Table3Forward maximum jumps59.71/1.68, five-day59.73/5.34, counts18/0, variation421.3/365.0RESULTS forward_smoothness/forward_total_variation; BOOT formula differences and grid to last pillarSupported; absolute successive changes distinct from variation
A18 §5.1Continuous B still has flat stretches and steep three-day rampRESULTS forward_after_3Y_node, sector counts; HW-CODE sectors ii/iii; retained figure visually inspectedSupported; continuity not equated to universal smoothness
A19 §5.15Y outside-window magnitude and absolute PV sensitivity shareBOOT comparisons use d<4Y or d>6Y; inside inclusive; ladder denominator sums absolute changes; RESULTS locality/ladder fieldsSupported; excludes netting and wrong interval endpoints
A20 §5.15Y76 prints not most traded; 10Y99QUOTES rows compared, rather than reading single countSupported ranking; wording corrected against possible false “most traded” claim
A21 §5.1B long-end forward4.6127→3.9957; average4.2013; ~20.6bp/67bp gapsRESULTS table; BOOT slice days[i20:i_last] excludes30Y node; QUOTES30Y4.6637Supported rounded arithmetic and exact population; no mixing with discreteAct365F forward
A22 §5.2QuantLib paper-setting failed; default blend differs; no-collar same on snapshotRESULTS interpolation_variants states failed at5th/3M, maxDF8.01175e-5, jump20.556; collar zero nodesSupported retained outcomes; failure not attributed to all B solvers
A23 §5.2–5.3Reasons/alternatives/limits for34 choicesBRIEF seven numbered choices and all Smaller choices bullets compared with Record2/document locatorsSupported attribution; no alternative invented for T01
A24 §6 Table4Historical execution times and versionsAll5 environment JSON receipts read, script hashes compared to fetched code; run_info versions agreeSupported receipt statements; not current runs or deployment
A25 §6Raw reproduction unavailable from selective bundleWE exclusions; original-raw-input-hashes; PROVENANCE inventory readSupported scope limitation; raw acquisition not attempted
A26 Table5All22 instruments satisfy .01bp, including max errorsCurrent code checked every A/B error column;22 rows; max3.86e-9/2.755e-10 from roundedCSV; RESULTS full precision agreesSupported current arithmetic, historical model calculation only
A27 Table6Historical paper, interval, positivity, continuity and roundtrip resultsCHECKS all named entries read against verify.py check definitions and tolerancesSupported retained tests; primary paper text remains unchecked
A28 §7.2 Table7A comparison max/mean and exact business-day boundsAll7,482 CSV row differences recomputed; max1.9251267247000214e-13, mean1.9170748626330293e-14; first/last dates checkedSupported independent arithmetic of retained series; no model reproduction
A29 §7.2Common schedules limit independence; B interpolation uses same nodesIMPL limits and summarize_implementations; VERIFY two_implementationsSupported scope; no independent institutional validation claim
A30 §7.3/Table8Signed residual order,983 cohorts523/140/320, heldout460RESIDUALS groups counted; VERIFY out_of_sample code and CHECKS summariesSupported; input-tenor prints excluded from heldout
A31 §7.3Historical median upper-middle rule, A.459942/B.404662, both<1bpVERIFY med_a/med_b code; frozen-row arithmetic reproduces B JSON0.4046620120479877 and A0.45994244105472537Supported; ordinary medians.458535/.404222 explicitly separate
A32 Table8Signed medians/quartiles differ from conventional interpolated quantilesVERIFY stats index int(p*(n−1)+.5) inspected; table copied from historical verify.mdSupported historical convention; no silent substitution
A33 Table9Paired counts/p-values/absolute-difference medians and cohortsCHECKS paired rows; VERIFY boundary lo<years≤hi, tolerance1e-9bp and upper-middle mediansSupported retained comparison; “under1Y” code endpoint explained
A34 §7.330/11 over41 versus16/6 over22 dates, p.004 vs.052; exploratory6M–1YCHECKS short, per-expiration, raw and exploratory rows inspected; BRIEF calls exploratorySupported; no independence or universal superiority inference
A35 §7.3B269/A189 with2 ties and aggregate+.007bpCHECKS all-heldout n460 counts, difference.0074033; arithmetic460−269−189=2Supported; count superiority not equated with economic materiality
A36 §7.3Late49 raw signed medians−.76/−.47, limited adjustmentCHECKS late row; VERIFY raw conversion and LATE_HOUR15; QUOTES hour15−.2/hour16zeroSupported; base curves still adjustment-dependent
A37 Table10Six distance bins, medians/IQR, exact distance from OIS pillarsRecomputed absolute calendar-distance bins and inclusive quartiles from RESIDUALS/NODES; all match DISTANCE JSON within1e-12Supported current arithmetic; no financial model rerun
A38 §7.3B median worse in nearest forward-start binTable10 forward0–30: B.598>A.578 despite aggregate B lowerSupported relational check; distance not independent validation/risk
A39 §7.4 Table11Convention scenario maxima versus baseline, annual and daycount exceed A/B differenceRESULTS convention_sensitivities fields; BOOT variants inspect scaling365/360; compare maxima with.00227458Supported scenario comparison; does not identify correct convention
A40 Figures1–4Axes/units, historical plots and data relationshipAll4PNG visually inspected; BOOT plotting calls and data CSV headers read; source files byte-matched and copiedSupported; first figure excludes time-zero point in plotting, per code
A41 §7.44.5Y cashflow PV difference sign and final-node roundingRESULTS off_node A−B=−269.4566; final jumpA≈8e-10bp/B0; 40Y DF/extrapolation fieldsSupported; rounded0 not asserted exact
A42 §8/§9Every major limitation has proposed control or explicit absent dedicated controlBRIEF limits compared with INST C01–C11 and documented event-step absenceSupported as simulated proposals; no operational evidence
A43 §10Fictional roles, inventory/tier, findings, pending committee/unsigned recordINST inventory, HER-CR-001, F01–F05 and Approval sections readSupported as supplied fiction only
A44 §11Versions/customization/shared dependencies/MIT distinctionReceipt package fields, imports/calls and WE license paragraph; LICENSE readSupported historical identity and licensing-scope description
A45 §12Complete SOFR notice and nonaffiliation retainedExact source-register notice compared with document subsectionSupported verbatim provider notice; not an independent legal analysis

B. Unchecked external source claims and unavailable evidence

ItemOriginal source/locator from supplied registerStatus and document treatment
HW2008 recommendation, comparison advice, positivity theorem and cubic-spline critique§6/6.1, pp.72–79, Table1Unchecked external contents: primary PDF not retrieved. Document identifies code behavior directly and attributes developer rationale to BRIEF; no paper title treated as proof
HW2006 par-equation provenance, examples/misprint, extrapolation and hedge/stability motivationpp.92,102,107,109,124–126Unchecked external contents. Retained tests and developer interpretation reported with source scope; alleged paper misprint not independently established
ARRC compounding/calendar/payment-delay descriptionpp.5,17,31,35Unchecked external contents. Implemented conventions supported by bundle code/brief; no external convention conformity certified
CFTC A004=Actual360 historical definitionHistorical specification AppendixC p.55Unchecked external contents. Described as brief attribution; data-code counts supported separately
DTCC guide's UTC report-day accountGuidev2.8 p.7Unchecked external contents. Developer timing rationale attributed; actual code converts timestamps to New York
CME planned transition and futures-convexity exampleAugust2020 §§1,1.3,2.1Unchecked external contents, historical-plan attribution only; no completed-transition/current-market claim
AB2013 multi-curve backgroundAbstract-level registered referenceUnchecked external contents; no implementation claim derived from title
QuantLib defaults and endpoint-only positivityVersion1.43 external source class/updateUnchecked external original source. Bundle helper arguments/code and retained comparison claims examined; default/endpoint rationale attributed to BRIEF/CHECKS
Original raw DTCC/NYFed inputs, raw extracted trade tablesRAW-HASHES and public origin linksUnavailable in selective bundle; not fetched/reconstructed. Prevents complete offline raw-data reproduction
Licensed benchmark and actual institution recordsINST required-real-world-gapsUnavailable:14 document markers preserve actual slots; simulated dossier cannot fill them
Broader dates, negative rates, stress regimes, full risk-system validationBRIEF limitations; INST F02/C07/C08Unavailable; current documentary/arithmetic scope does not create evidence

No unresolved material contradiction is concealed. The nearest-index median convention explains the small difference between historical median displays and ordinary two-middle medians. The convenient kernel alias and selected pin have identical bytes and release. The source brief's corrected “approximately0.40bp” aligns with retained0.404662bp; the document does not repeat an unsupported0.41bp result. Numerical equality from rounded display values is not asserted.

Record 4 — Readiness report

Exact document SHA-256: 16d7918bc07263bef7f90b9ed2aa9f407ff01a3a28da4c3085c081f87ddca2bf
Document: document.md, demo-v1, 2026-10-12; as-of: 2026-09-18.
Selected inputs: revision 01ae3bdac6f61ecbabcd72e0116ebb2860e93157; dossier HER-scenario-1; kernel/Quant release 0.4.6-rc.1. input-manifest.json records every retained input origin, final URL, acquisition time and SHA-256. selected-dependencies.json declares six agreement hashes; each matched. Public bundle files used here matched SHA256SUMS where declared.

Judgment: The commissioned documentation scope is fulfilled at executor readiness level: a substantive twelve-section document, every selected requirement mapped, all 34 developer choice entries retained, a performed citation audit, exact artifact identification and an honest result record. The document is ready for a separate assessment of these exact bytes. This is not a statement that actual institutional evidence is complete, that the model is validated, or that any real use is authorized.

Findings and remaining work:

  1. Material evidence limit: One historical positive-rate snapshot and selected developer tests do not establish general validity, negative-rate behavior, stressed performance, long-end truth or comprehensive hedging stability. A separately authorized, retained multi-date/stress/risk campaign and independent assessment remain needed for broader reliance.
  2. Benchmark and input limit: Derived public execution estimates share an intraday adjustment with outside-input comparisons. No licensed independent benchmark or real feed lineage/tolerance exists in supplied evidence. Original raw inputs are omitted; full raw-data reproduction is not possible from this selective offline bundle.
  3. Implementation limit: A's7,482-point implementation agreement is strong arithmetic agreement conditional on shared inputs/dates. It does not remove common calendar/convention defects. Separate schedule reconstruction remains needed.
  4. External-source limit: Original papers and external versioned code were not retrieved; their claims remain expressly attributed to the brief or historical check report, with unchecked status in Record3. A later assessment may obtain and verify the primary sources, particularly the paper-example interpretation and collar/convention assertions. The document does not present these as independently established facts.
  5. Institutional limit: All dossier facts and controls are fictional. The 14 marked actual evidence gaps remain substantive absences: inventory/tier; internal feed/entitlements; exposure/use inventory; real roles/authorization; prior validation; approval conditions; operating monitoring; production conventions; benchmark/tolerance; close/stale policy; extrapolation policy; risk bump methodology; implementation ticket; signatures. Their disclosure is complete; their supply is not.
  6. Assessment limit: This readiness report was prepared by the executor that wrote the document. Independent assessment and any institutional authorization are separate and pending. The fictional F-05 record is not retroactively closed on behalf of its named roles.

Checks actually performed now: Pinned/bundle byte verification; all 22 A/B error-column comparisons with 0.01 bp; monthly-grid row/maximum/date inspection and full-precision USD conversion; all 7,482 retained implementation-difference calculations plus mean/max; held-out cohort counts and upper-middle median check; all six distance-bin summaries recomputed from frozen rows with inclusive quartiles; source-function inspection; visual inspection of four frozen figures; requirement/choice/claim mapping and artifact-structure checks. These are document readiness and arithmetic checks, not financial-model reruns. Machine-readable arithmetic evidence is in checks.json; the current checking script imports no financial-model modules.

No new source/model run: Original derive_quotes.py, bootstrap.py, hagan_west.py, verify.py and other supplied scripts were inspected only. Historical stage receipts were not relabeled as current execution. No actual institutional approval, deployment, independent review, trading, publication, package installation or source amendment occurred.

result.md

Download raw Markdown
Sections in result.md

Result — USD SOFR documentation commission

Channel: out (normal completed documentation result).
Documentation scope: fulfilled at executor readiness level; separate assessment and actual institutional authorization remain pending.
Output directory: /private/var/folders/hz/g34mr1l52fn8d1y65j6gmq_80000gn/T/openprose-sofr-20261012-r01-ifbmpali
Executor: Codex subagent /root/sofr_executor_01; exact underlying model identifier is not exposed in this invocation and is unknown.
First observed current time: 2026-10-12 14:29:08 UTC (10:29:08 America/New_York). This is the first observed execution time, not an invented dispatch timestamp.
Record creation time: 2026-10-12T14:45:43.766203+00:00 (UTC).
Observed interval from first clock reading: 995.8 seconds; does not claim a separately observed dispatch duration.
Execution limit honored: work completed before the caller's 20-minute boundary and absolute 2026-10-12 10:50 ET stop; no continuation scheduled.

Selected agreement and input identities

The convenient kernel URL redirected to https://pkg.prose.md/releases/0.4.6-rc.1/core/README.md. Its bytes match the exact selected pin. The invocation explicitly selects release 0.4.6-rc.1, adopting Quant documentation and its nested model-description, numerical-evidence, claim-evidence and institutional-facts definitions, plus the supplied base and house requirements. Definitions were read from their own public origins; local caching did not relocate their dependency context. No package installation or package resolver invocation occurred.

The retrieved program origin and final URL are both https://openprose.ai/demos/sofr/v1/program.md. Its SHA-256 is ad458104fe99c7e1b0683558dd4cc8843d4756ba902dd7b7b9534a96cca859f9. Source revision is 01ae3bdac6f61ecbabcd72e0116ebb2860e93157, input as-of 2026-09-18, spot 2026-09-22; institutional dossier revision HER-scenario-1, authored 2026-10-12. Historical numerical receipts dated 2026-10-02 are inputs to this new documentation run.

Retained definition/programRequested public originRetrieved SHA-256
inputs/kernel-alias.mdhttps://pkg.prose.md/kernel.md4622c21aa110d36abc9262496f922e578ecd9eb20e87241b28b2060d06df36cb
inputs/kernel.mdhttps://pkg.prose.md/releases/0.4.6-rc.1/core/README.md4622c21aa110d36abc9262496f922e578ecd9eb20e87241b28b2060d06df36cb
inputs/documentation.mdhttps://pkg.prose.md/releases/0.4.6-rc.1/quant/contracts/documentation.md80e8b260d5cfbd87abf63a5d94ee3e33387645775054eab599beeeccef9e2072
inputs/model-description.mdhttps://pkg.prose.md/releases/0.4.6-rc.1/quant/contracts/model-description.md8a48a2f1ff8bea197026b3ba433ebb36cf9cfeb739cfd35b2eddfe992fe0c574
inputs/numerical-evidence.mdhttps://pkg.prose.md/releases/0.4.6-rc.1/quant/contracts/numerical-evidence.mdf4c14d6118d1a1846c5e1d60468a1af33c8b603e2d07949ed55dd0dd3035bd94
inputs/claim-evidence.mdhttps://pkg.prose.md/releases/0.4.6-rc.1/quant/contracts/claim-evidence.mdb023aeb88dc481b6cf31aff630a7adab28e52979827f5c6ecfda8861063d207c
inputs/institutional-facts.mdhttps://pkg.prose.md/releases/0.4.6-rc.1/quant/contracts/institutional-facts.mdcfb18dc33211a4b511e8af40172596a4f9df592a3d99d41c93da877fd0b10ed1
inputs/program.mdhttps://openprose.ai/demos/sofr/v1/program.mdad458104fe99c7e1b0683558dd4cc8843d4756ba902dd7b7b9534a96cca859f9

All six selected definition hashes match the bundle's selected-dependencies.json. The public files with declared entries match inputs/SHA256SUMS. The complete 61-record acquisition inventory is input-manifest.json: requested and final addresses, actual retrieval times, local paths, SHA-256 values and declared-hash comparisons. This includes acquired supporting files, some cached for reference even where not substantively used; the citation audit identifies the sources actually relied upon. Hash checks establish byte identity under the public bundle's declarations, not model truth or general agent conformance.

Delivered artifacts

ArtifactActual absolute pathSHA-256
document.md/private/var/folders/hz/g34mr1l52fn8d1y65j6gmq_80000gn/T/openprose-sofr-20261012-r01-ifbmpali/document.md16d7918bc07263bef7f90b9ed2aa9f407ff01a3a28da4c3085c081f87ddca2bf
reviews.md/private/var/folders/hz/g34mr1l52fn8d1y65j6gmq_80000gn/T/openprose-sofr-20261012-r01-ifbmpali/reviews.md17c4ea54770d26f7fe4c04cc0ce4fb2b942d253fcbe10382b67ddf70c264cde8
checks.json/private/var/folders/hz/g34mr1l52fn8d1y65j6gmq_80000gn/T/openprose-sofr-20261012-r01-ifbmpali/checks.jsonafb21d0b01a07b2f56eb6b07f7375a4e95fc6c6699e506b47461666db79dbd5d
input-manifest.json/private/var/folders/hz/g34mr1l52fn8d1y65j6gmq_80000gn/T/openprose-sofr-20261012-r01-ifbmpali/input-manifest.json01a1ddb18fb620fd285715c280a44927aacb281730f39a35e503f486008945f1
inspect_evidence.py/private/var/folders/hz/g34mr1l52fn8d1y65j6gmq_80000gn/T/openprose-sofr-20261012-r01-ifbmpali/inspect_evidence.py938bb2b61b37893e4c764b3910ddfeecaf5ef1bdcafe82834ad60c5c781ce061
complete_document.py/private/var/folders/hz/g34mr1l52fn8d1y65j6gmq_80000gn/T/openprose-sofr-20261012-r01-ifbmpali/complete_document.pyc82910f680b68a7b9638ffd264b48f37a6bbf18aa489b40d33942f996cd1c53b
finalize_records.py/private/var/folders/hz/g34mr1l52fn8d1y65j6gmq_80000gn/T/openprose-sofr-20261012-r01-ifbmpali/finalize_records.pya76471f71ce68cf289b0682f2a7ea079ae021768a54e011ab9950471b8fc8e78
figures/fig_discount_factors.png/private/var/folders/hz/g34mr1l52fn8d1y65j6gmq_80000gn/T/openprose-sofr-20261012-r01-ifbmpali/figures/fig_discount_factors.png25479261e6d8a12aa06936b8df47b7d4a6fa827d62ab948fbb4a144340709013
figures/fig_forwards.png/private/var/folders/hz/g34mr1l52fn8d1y65j6gmq_80000gn/T/openprose-sofr-20261012-r01-ifbmpali/figures/fig_forwards.png618e106048b281bba00661225174bd3d87696804c7fcf5b3a17432e29467c56b
figures/fig_bump_5y.png/private/var/folders/hz/g34mr1l52fn8d1y65j6gmq_80000gn/T/openprose-sofr-20261012-r01-ifbmpali/figures/fig_bump_5y.png4ddbc761a4b8345dc23af3ffe774e7fe2ded88fce079d89a20c31ab51e938c8a
figures/fig_delta_ladder.png/private/var/folders/hz/g34mr1l52fn8d1y65j6gmq_80000gn/T/openprose-sofr-20261012-r01-ifbmpali/figures/fig_delta_ladder.png338447c00027d61cac32da9ae61cae48a5a571e0f540ed2056f7bd74d260bebb

document.md contains all twelve exact numbered house sections, front matter, equations, complete calibration evidence, signed and absolute residual comparisons, end-date bins, limitations/controls, assumptions, simulated institutional record, references and both required disclaimers. Its prose count excluding table rows/reference-list bullets is 7,195; the whitespace count including table markup and references is 10,572. The commission's length target is advisory; retained evidence tables account for the difference.

reviews.md contains four separate records: requirement-by-requirement section plan, all 34 principal/smaller choices, a performed claim audit with support/unchecked/unavailable statuses, and readiness tied to the exact document hash. It assesses report requirements against reports and document requirements against the document.

The companion artifact-manifest.json records paths, sizes and SHA-256 for all retained files except itself, including result.md. Its separate location avoids an impossible self-referential hash inside result.md. Acquired evidence remains under inputs/; four figures are copied byte-for-byte under figures/ and referenced relatively for offline reading.

Checks actually performed

  • Read the program, pinned kernel, all five Quant contracts, base/house requirements, brief, sources, source manifest, provenance and fictional dossier. Resolved declared nested adoptions; no incompatible release detected.
  • Acquired named public evidence and code with User-Agent: OpenProse/0.1 on the tracked retrievals. Verified six declared agreement hashes and bundle-declared hashes; checked every cached file against the acquisition manifest. Read original source paths only as provenance; never accessed the private repository.
  • Inspected the calculation functions to establish pricing formulas, date/calendar conventions, monthly/business-day grids, exact bump-window endpoints, sign conventions, solver thresholds, quantile rules and component dependencies. Original model scripts were not executed or imported.
  • Ran python3 inspect_evidence.py in this directory. This uses only standard-library arithmetic over frozen CSV/JSON: all 22 A/B calibration errors satisfy 0.01 bp; 361 monthly rows have the specified bounds and maximum date; full-precision JSON DF difference times USD100m gives USD227,458.19731463946; all 7,482 retained implementation differences match, with exact max/mean; held-out cohort counts and six distance-bin medians/IQRs were checked.
  • Performed additional inline standard-library arithmetic using Python 3.14.6: reproduced historical signed summary/nearest-index quantile values for all ten cohort/method combinations; confirmed upper-middle held-out medians A0.45994244105472537 bp and B0.4046620120479877 bp; confirmed B269/A189/two ties and aggregate sign-test arithmetic. The different ordinary two-center medians were recorded rather than silently substituted.
  • Compared each of five stage-receipt script hashes with the acquired script bytes; all matched. These checks do not make the historical stage receipts current runs.
  • Visually inspected all four copied figures for axes, units and correspondence with the source plotting code. Checked exact twelve headings, local image targets, absence of placeholders, 14 institutional gap markers, verbatim house disclaimer and complete verbatim provider notice. Checked citations/relationships and all principal/smaller choices against source locators; details are in reviews.md.
  • Wrote the document and completed its evidence tables with python3 complete_document.py. Wrote this result/companion manifest with python3 finalize_records.py. File creation and arithmetic inspection are the only local execution effects; no financial calculation is represented as reproduced.

Machine-readable outcomes and current timestamps are in checks.json. Current documentation-check Python identity is 3.14.6; it is separate from historical model Python3.12.14. Current user/system/model identities not otherwise exposed remain unknown.

Observed effects and failures

Effects were public HTTP retrieval, creation of local input copies, creation of the requested Markdown artifacts and supporting records/scripts, and local figure copies, confined to the caller's fresh directory. Initial duplicate scratch kernel.md and program.md copies were removed after verified copies under inputs/ existed. No accepted shared state, source data, code, previous run, developer repository, prior answer, remote publication, account, message recipient, institution or trading system was changed.

The first web-open attempts returned tool-level “not accessible” responses for the two launch URLs. Available HTTP clients then retrieved both successfully, followed redirects and recorded their identities. This was a recovered acquisition-tool limitation, not a remaining execution failure. No unresolved fetch, hash mismatch, write or arithmetic-check failure remains.

Evidence limits, unfinished work and continuation

No required documentation artifact or supporting report is left unfinished. The following substantive evidence remains outside or unavailable within this commission, and disclosure does not supply it:

  • Independent assessment of the exact document bytes, and actual institutional validation, authorization and sign-offs.
  • A licensed benchmark, real internal feed/entitlement lineage, actual exposures, actual inventory/tier/roles, operating control and monitoring records, approvals/conditions, implementation tickets and the other 14 marked real-world evidence slots.
  • Multi-date, stressed/negative-rate, full risk-system and separately sourced schedule/calendar studies. One date and shared adjustment/schedules limit current comparisons.
  • Original raw archives/snapshots and omitted trade tables needed for full raw-data reproduction. This selective bundle permits numerical inspection, not a complete offline model rerun.
  • Primary-paper and external-source assertions independently checked against their originals. Those contents were not retrieved; the document preserves them as developer attributions with explicit audit status, rather than treating titles as support. The code and frozen tests are available for implementation-specific statements.

The final readiness conclusion applies to documentation scope only. A later assessor should use the exact document hash in reviews.md, the input identities in input-manifest.json, and the findings there. Any edits create new document bytes and require a newly identified assessment target. No current or future institutional approval is inferred.

Assessment · ASSESSMENT.md

Download raw Markdown
Sections in ASSESSMENT.md

Independent assessment — frozen SOFR documentation executor 01

Recommendation: Suitable as a clearly labeled recorded documentation demonstration with this assessment and finding F-01 visible. It is not suitable for presentation as an unqualified, fully fulfilled methodology result. The document is substantial and the principal A/B comparison is well supported by the supplied numerical evidence, but it accepts an inconsistent day-count sensitivity interpretation from the source. No institutional validation, regulatory approval, production acceptance or broad agent-reliability conclusion follows.

Assessment result: out — completed bounded independent evaluation, with an unmet subject requirement identified. Subject implementation was not repaired.

QuestionJudgment
Did execution produce the requested artifacts?Yes, directly observed: complete twelve-section document.md, four supporting records in reviews.md, result.md, retained inputs, figures and manifests. No artifact-generation failure is apparent. Upstream process completion and recovered tool failures are executor reports, not independently observed tool events.
Is the selected agreement wholly fulfilled?Partly fulfilled. Most documentary obligations are met. F-01 prevents unqualified fulfillment of the numerical-meaning/claim-support duties and makes the all-met readiness declaration too strong. This is a substantive interpretation issue, not an omitted artifact or a demand for an unauthorized model rerun.
Is the result adequate for its intended use?Broadly useful to a quantitative reviewer; adequate for a recorded demonstration only when the outstanding finding and evidence limits remain visible. It is not a basis for live pricing or real institutional acceptance.

Target, identity and review boundary

Evaluator: Codex delegated agent /root/sofr_evaluator_01, assigned by /root. The served model identifier and usage are not exposed; none is asserted. First observed clock: 2026-10-12 14:46:29 UTC / 10:46:29 America/New_York. That is a clock observation, not an invented dispatch timestamp. The assignment permits at most eight minutes from dispatch and requires an absolute stop at 10:55 ET. Completion time is recorded at the end.

Frozen target: ../executor-01/, specifically the files hashed below. Original executor output path is the temporary directory recorded in its result.md; I evaluated the coordinator's frozen copy. Observable worktree branch: codex/imp-130-sofr-demo. Ownership here is limited to this assessment directory; no subject, source or shared task record was edited, and no commit or publication was made.

The subject agreement is the public commission at https://openprose.ai/demos/sofr/v1/program.md, selecting kernel and Quant release 0.4.6-rc.1, base requirements, house requirements and fictional institution dossier. I read the frozen agreement copies, including all five Quant definitions and the kernel, full base/house requirements, developer brief, institutional dossier, source register and manifest. Their public origins remain their reference origins; local paths do not relocate adopted definitions. Source revision is 01ae3bdac6f61ecbabcd72e0116ebb2860e93157; numerical as-of is 2026-09-18, spot 2026-09-22; scenario revision is HER-scenario-1.

I read the full submitted document and all four review records and result. I inspected its three supporting Python scripts without running them, inspected selected financial source functions, read retained numerical summaries and selected receipts, performed independent arithmetic on the frozen rows, and visually inspected all four copied PNG figures. No earlier answer, other evaluator report or private source repository was used. No nested agent, source-script execution/import, direct model API call, credential access, installation, model rerun or publication occurred in this assessment. Own checks use the available Python 3.14.6 standard library and write only here.

Full upstream tool-event coverage was not supplied. I cannot independently establish what the executor actually read, its complete context, absence of forbidden actions, whether its context was isolated, its model identity, or the claimed dispatch-duration compliance from final artifacts alone. Its acquisition times, redirect observations and action history remain executor reports supported by retained manifests, not observations of those HTTP/tool events. Agreement-byte identity can be checked locally; actual enactment is a separate question.

Findings

F-01 — Material: day-count sensitivity label is inconsistent with the implemented transformation

Locations: document.md lines 368–379, particularly Table 11's “Fixed leg interpreted Act/365F rather than Act/360” row and its explanatory sentence; the corresponding assumption in Table 13; reviews.md audit A39 and its all-met readiness conclusion. Supporting source: frozen inputs/model-source/bootstrap.py lines 287–291, ql_helpers/hw_instruments, and the par relation in document §3.1.

The code retains Act/360 instruments but multiplies each quote by 365/360. The document reports that implementation detail accurately. It nevertheless calls the resulting maximum DF differences, 0.00500070 and 0.00500142, the sensitivity to interpreting the unchanged fixed coupon under Act/365F. The source comment asserts the same relationship, so copying it does not resolve the inconsistency.

For a fixed coupon rate r over d days, Act/365F pays r*d/365. The equivalent rate in an unchanged Act/360 instrument solves r_equiv*d/360 = r*d/365, giving r_equiv = r*360/365, the reciprocal of the implemented scaling. As a scalar check only, a 4.5% coupon over 360 days pays 0.04438356164 per unit notional under Act/365F; the code's scaled Act/360 coupon pays 0.045625. This uses the supplied cash-flow relation; no curve was reconstructed.

Thus the retained numbers support the implemented upward coupon perturbation, not the stated unchanged-coupon day-count switch. Their exact values for the intended switch are unknown within this assessment. Because this is a nonlinear recalibration, one must not merely reverse their signs or reuse their magnitudes. The quarterly sensitivity independently remains larger than the A/B maximum, so this finding does not invalidate that separate comparison or the headline USD 227,458 single-payment disagreement.

The commission did not authorize repairing the financial model. The documentation could have fulfilled its conflict-reporting duty by preserving the historical numbers with the literal transformation, marking the intended day-count interpretation unresolved, and carrying that finding into the audit/readiness result. It instead marks A39 supported without qualification. Relevant duties: numerical-evidence meaning and conditions; claim-evidence asserted relationship/conflict reporting; R-05, R-09, R-31, R-40 and R-62. These are partly met where affected. A qualified annotation in a new document would produce new bytes and require a newly identified assessment target; this frozen version is unchanged.

P-01 — Minor presentation issue: inline mathematical markup needs a viewing check

The source uses ordinary parentheses around TeX expressions, for example \alpha, \log, subscripts and 8.0\times10^{-10} in §§3 and 7.4, rather than inline math delimiters. A plain Markdown rendering may display these commands literally. Displayed equations are separately delimited. I inspected Markdown source and figures, not a rendered document in the final presentation surface, so the actual rendering effect is unverified. This is a readability/presentation concern, not evidence that the underlying equations are wrong.

Independent evidence checks

The reproducible local arithmetic records are independent_checks.py / independent_checks.json and supplement_checks.py / supplement_checks.json. They do not execute any supplied financial code.

  • Byte identities: All 73 entries in the submitted artifact manifest match their frozen files. All 61 acquisition-manifest entries match. All 53 present files declared in the public bundle SHA256SUMS match; presenter.md is not cached. The latter is optional presenter guidance, not an adopted methodology dependency, so its absence is not a fulfillment defect. All four local figure copies match their input PNG bytes.
  • Structure and notices: Twelve exact numbered house headings, substantive sections, front matter, three-sentence conclusion, assumptions and control tables, citations, 14 institutional gap markers, verbatim demonstration disclaimer and complete provider notice are present. The advisory word target is not treated as a hard limit. There is no process checklist substituted for the model narrative.
  • Calibration: Independently compared every Table 5 entry with every one of the 22 CSV rows, both error columns and input rate. No mismatch. Every absolute error is below 0.01 bp; CSV maxima are A 3.86e-9 and B 2.755e-10 bp. The higher-precision JSON numbers support the finer displayed maxima elsewhere. This checks the retained error columns, not the underlying calibration engine.
  • A/B economic comparison: Monthly grid has 361 rows, 2026-09-18 through 2056-09-18. Largest retained difference row is 2050-04-18, A greater than B. Full-precision JSON difference 0.0022745819731463945 times USD 100 million is USD 227,458.19731463946. The document's rounded USD 227,458.20 and single-cash-flow interpretation are supported. Rounded CSV DFs alone cannot establish cents, and the document says so.
  • Method A implementation comparison: Recomputed all 7,482 absolute row differences. Each agrees with the retained difference column; maximum is 1.9251267247000214e-13, mean of magnitudes 1.9170748626330293e-14. Exact bounds 2026-09-18 through 2056-09-26 are preserved. Business-day identity follows inspected source/calendar selection; I did not independently reconstruct the SOFR holiday calendar. This is correctly distinguished from A/B method disagreement and from institutional independence.
  • Residual populations and statistics: Independently counted 523 input-tenor spot prints, 140 other-maturity spot prints and 320 forward-start prints, hence 460 held out. Upper-middle absolute medians reproduce A 0.4599424411 and B 0.4046620120 bp; both meet the selected 1 bp criterion. Ordinary medians differ as disclosed. All ten historical signed-summary cohort/method results and all twelve paired-comparison rows, including p-values and robustness selections, independently reproduce from the supplied residual CSV with the inspected conventions. B/A closer counts are 269/189 plus two ties. This does not create independent market observations.
  • Distance bins: Recomputed all six cohort/bin counts, medians and inclusive IQRs from expiration-to-nearest-OIS-payment-pillar calendar-day distances, excluding deposits. All match the retained JSON and displayed rounding. The document preserves 0–30, 31–90, >90 boundaries and keeps cohorts separate; it identifies B's worse nearest-bin forward-start median and does not call distance a risk or independence measure.
  • Shape/locality: From rounded retained forward CSV, verified the A/B maximum daily moves, counts above 2 bp, and five-business-day moves at displayed precision. Inspected the source's grid construction through the last node, positivity collar and inactive-collar result, solver guard, extrapolation and plotting code. Bump maxima strictly outside the inclusive 4Y–6Y node window reproduce 0.0305/4.1475 bp. Absolute ladder shares reproduce 5.86%/11.94% after rounding. The default QuantLib blend and failed paper-setting solver attempt are correctly distinguished; the failure is retained, not hidden.
  • Precision limit: Summing changes from the rounded A forward CSV gives 421.3685 bp rather than full-precision JSON 421.3288736704 bp. Accumulated rounding can explain that gap: a conservative bound from 7,481 differences and six-decimal-percent rounding is 0.7481 bp. I therefore do not call this a contradiction or claim exact reproduction of the unrounded total variation. The document correctly uses JSON precision.
  • Figures: Four observed PNGs have readable axes, units and legends; captions supply historical date, calculation/data identity and relevant interpretation limits. The required discount-factor, forward and bump/ladder content is present with local relative references. I did not regenerate figures or numerically recover every plotted pixel.

Coverage of the agreement and supporting records

Selected scopeIndependent assessment
R-01, R-02, R-03: purpose, use/exclusions, constructionMet on inspected content: plain-language explanation, single-curve scope, lagged cash-flow relation, dates, time basis, A/B construction, solver and extrapolation account are substantive. No attempt here to prove general interpolation properties.
R-04: inputs and provenanceMet as documentation of supplied evidence. Real fixing, reported prints, derived estimates and scenario fiction are distinct; raw-source truth is not newly verified.
R-05: retained testsPartly met because F-01 misinterprets one scenario; other checked tests are accurately labeled historical, with all calibration errors supplied.
R-06: outside-input and implementation comparisonsMet on the extensive numerical checks above; signs, populations, shared adjustment/schedules and lack of licensed benchmark are explicit.
R-07, R-08: limits and controlsMet: one date, sparse long end, locality, common adjustment, extrapolation, missing event steps, calendar and stress limits; proposed fictional controls and absent effectiveness are distinguished.
R-09: assumptionsPartly met: substantial reason/evidence/consequence/monitoring register, but day-count consequence inherits F-01.
R-10, R-11: fictional monitoring/governanceMet as scenario documentation; pending approval, unsigned block and actual-evidence gaps preserved. Fiction does not establish real controls.
R-12, R-13: components and retrievable evidenceMet as historical identities and public-origin references. Selected external paper/code assertions remain attributed and explicitly unchecked.
R-20: every principal/smaller choiceSeven principal and 27 smaller entries are represented, with reasons, alternatives and limits. I compared the full brief's choice inventory with the register and document destinations; no missing choice identified. F-01 remains an interpretation finding, not an omitted choice.
R-21: principal comparisonMet: specified single payment, signs/units and smoothness/locality tradeoff supported. No profit, superiority or portfolio-loss inference.
R-30: reproducibility and identitiesMet as supplied provenance and scope explanation; raw archives and original external papers unavailable locally, no offline raw-data rerun claimed.
R-31: measure traceabilityMostly met, partly affected by F-01's scenario meaning. Dates, grids, units and scripts otherwise extensively supplied.
R-40: factual claim relationshipsPartly met: a substantive audit and generally precise support, but the source/meaning mismatch in A39 was not surfaced.
R-41: permitted sourcesCompatible with observed artifacts; actual full acquisition behavior cannot be established without upstream tool events. External contents are not asserted as independently verified.
R-50, R-60, R-61: institutional gaps and readiness distinctionsMet in document presentation: scenario labels, 14 real gaps, disclaimers, executor versus independent assessment and actual authorization kept separate.
R-62: requirement-by-requirement reportStructurally met, judgment partly met: every base requirement is mapped, but all-met/full-fulfillment declaration should be qualified by F-01.
Supporting section planFull requirement mapping with document/report locators, not merely an outline.
Supporting choice register34 identified entries with reason, alternative/explicit absence, limitation and evidence; substantive.
Supporting citation audit45 checks plus explicit unchecked/unavailable categories. It goes beyond a citation list; F-01 demonstrates its limitation and prevents blanket acceptance of every “Supported” conclusion.
Supporting readiness/resultExact artifact identities and unresolved broader work recorded; self-readiness is correctly labeled as executor work. Its completeness judgment is too strong in light of F-01. Process/boundary claims remain reports rather than independently observed events.

Remaining uncertainty and demonstration use

I did not acquire external primary papers or versioned QuantLib originals; verify their substantive assertions separately if the demonstration will characterize them as checked facts. I did not recover the omitted raw DTCC/NY Fed data, reconstruct any model, independently build calendars, test additional dates or regimes, validate actual institution records, or audit every line of every source script. Code inspection was targeted to material method, population, sign, tolerance and scenario claims. Arithmetic checks have full row coverage only where explicitly stated above. Historical environmental receipt contents identify supplied historical runs, not proof that those runs were independently reproduced today.

The exact document can be shown with its frozen artifact hash, its own disclosures, and this assessment's F-01 clearly visible. Describe it as a recorded documentation execution subjected to this bounded assessment, with one unresolved material interpretation finding. Do not present its “fulfilled” line without the assessment qualification. Any source correction, new numerical run or document revision should be separately authorized, retain this evidence and receive its own identity and assessment. Real institutional evidence and authorization remain outside this demonstration.

Exact byte identities

All paths below are relative to the frozen ../executor-01/. independent_checks.json contains SHA-256 values for every frozen file, including all selected definitions, all numerical CSV/JSON, scripts, figures and manifests.

ArtifactSHA-256
document.md16d7918bc07263bef7f90b9ed2aa9f407ff01a3a28da4c3085c081f87ddca2bf
reviews.md17c4ea54770d26f7fe4c04cc0ce4fb2b942d253fcbe10382b67ddf70c264cde8
result.md23fdb6889fa34cec8bfe43c34375ef3d1ffe5cbb48dfb413f076fb33d6a977a0
artifact-manifest.jsonbc916154450fdba44381bc0781839d2be2a56927f75d18cdda41d87cf10e9d63
input-manifest.json01a1ddb18fb620fd285715c280a44927aacb281730f39a35e503f486008945f1
inputs/program.mdad458104fe99c7e1b0683558dd4cc8843d4756ba902dd7b7b9534a96cca859f9
inputs/kernel.md4622c21aa110d36abc9262496f922e578ecd9eb20e87241b28b2060d06df36cb
inputs/model-brief.mda3262b78cd21a770b4c446508d1cb681610f2ab760bc23bbff35bf96b5333c74
inputs/requirements.md9e0965eb4e8c9c13ad9383049a2377cd053e39bc575a99b693ed882144b4a8bb
inputs/house.md85f083dae309d17a4862a27997a56b58ffac5ed7bc95645d8e6c3f2ae8b3c783
inputs/model-source/bootstrap.pyd897203d1b145f81b60248df422ef79411362a212098e0408a05fb757f3e56b2
inputs/evidence/repricing.csv70d1e851114cc2326121fd615dd4da158bd505e12cf29afdb5adf9f791a63f5e
inputs/evidence/oos_residuals.csv28dc38fafd4ca94665217a792eb414d0dca3f090b4b0a7a0244f3b0f6214b58e
inputs/evidence/implementation-comparison.csv06408929119a4b61259e9114e57951940f204e25068def2099e1727281b550da

Assessment completed: 2026-10-12T14:52:25.602591+00:00 UTC (America/New_York is UTC−04:00 on this date). Frozen file hashes rechecked at completion: no changes from the assessed target. Completion is before the absolute stop and under eight minutes after the first observed clock; an exact dispatch timestamp was not supplied to this evaluator.